Press "Enter" to skip to content

Symbols and their Consequences in the Sex Robot Debate | John Danaher | TEDxWHU


[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] there’s a cave about 350 kilometers from

there’s a cave about 350 kilometers from

there’s a cave about 350 kilometers from here it’s in the swampy Endora and it’s

here it’s in the swampy Endora and it’s

here it’s in the swampy Endora and it’s called the holy fells sorry this is a

called the holy fells sorry this is a

called the holy fells sorry this is a picture of the entrance to the cave an

picture of the entrance to the cave an

picture of the entrance to the cave an archaeologists have been excavating this

archaeologists have been excavating this

archaeologists have been excavating this caves it’s the late 1800s

caves it’s the late 1800s

caves it’s the late 1800s and they’ve discovered there a number of

and they’ve discovered there a number of

and they’ve discovered there a number of important artifacts from the Upper

important artifacts from the Upper

important artifacts from the Upper Paleolithic era in June of 2005 they

Paleolithic era in June of 2005 they

Paleolithic era in June of 2005 they announced a particularly interesting

announced a particularly interesting

announced a particularly interesting discovery they had unearthed an unusual

discovery they had unearthed an unusual

discovery they had unearthed an unusual object it was 20 centimeters long 3

object it was 20 centimeters long 3

object it was 20 centimeters long 3 centimeters wide it was made from highly

centimeters wide it was made from highly

centimeters wide it was made from highly polished stone and its intended function

polished stone and its intended function

polished stone and its intended function was according to the leader of the dig

was according to the leader of the dig

was according to the leader of the dig team Nicholas Cunard clearly

team Nicholas Cunard clearly

team Nicholas Cunard clearly recognizable so I’m gonna put a picture

recognizable so I’m gonna put a picture

recognizable so I’m gonna put a picture of it up and screen now I’m gonna see if

of it up and screen now I’m gonna see if

of it up and screen now I’m gonna see if you agree with him I’ll give you a hint

you agree with him I’ll give you a hint

you agree with him I’ll give you a hint it’s supposed to be a human body part so

it’s supposed to be a human body part so

it’s supposed to be a human body part so I’m not going to state the obvious but

I’m not going to state the obvious but

I’m not going to state the obvious but artifacts of this sort have been

artifacts of this sort have been

artifacts of this sort have been discovered in various sites around the

discovered in various sites around the

discovered in various sites around the world dating back tens of thousands of

world dating back tens of thousands of

world dating back tens of thousands of years this one was estimated to be

years this one was estimated to be

years this one was estimated to be 28,000 years old and you may wonder why

28,000 years old and you may wonder why

28,000 years old and you may wonder why I’m telling you this I’m telling you it

I’m telling you this I’m telling you it

I’m telling you this I’m telling you it because it hopefully illustrates the

because it hopefully illustrates the

because it hopefully illustrates the long history that human beings have had

long history that human beings have had

long history that human beings have had with the creation of artifacts for the

with the creation of artifacts for the

with the creation of artifacts for the purposes of sexual stimulation that

purposes of sexual stimulation that

purposes of sexual stimulation that history dates back to the Holy Fell’s

history dates back to the Holy Fell’s

history dates back to the Holy Fell’s artifact but also through to the

artifact but also through to the

artifact but also through to the construction of the first mechanical and

construction of the first mechanical and

construction of the first mechanical and electronic vibrators in the mid to late

electronic vibrators in the mid to late

electronic vibrators in the mid to late 1800s and through to the dazzling

1800s and through to the dazzling

1800s and through to the dazzling diversity of sex toys that are available

diversity of sex toys that are available

diversity of sex toys that are available on the market today now in January of

on the market today now in January of

on the market today now in January of 2010 we got a glimpse before the future

2010 we got a glimpse before the future

2010 we got a glimpse before the future of this industry in a lie at the adult

of this industry in a lie at the adult

of this industry in a lie at the adult video network Expo in Las Vegas Nevada

video network Expo in Las Vegas Nevada

video network Expo in Las Vegas Nevada Douglas Heinz the owner of a company

Douglas Heinz the owner of a company

Douglas Heinz the owner of a company called true companion unveiled Roxy

called true companion unveiled Roxy

called true companion unveiled Roxy which we billed as the world’s first sex

which we billed as the world’s first sex

which we billed as the world’s first sex robot now sex robots have been a

robot now sex robots have been a

robot now sex robots have been a long-standing trope or idea in science

long-standing trope or idea in science

long-standing trope or idea in science fiction but it now looks as though

fiction but it now looks as though

fiction but it now looks as though they’re going to become a reality and

they’re going to become a reality and

they’re going to become a reality and indeed since 20

indeed since 20

indeed since 20 and a number of other companies have

and a number of other companies have

and a number of other companies have entered into the market and developed

entered into the market and developed

entered into the market and developed prototype models including most notably

prototype models including most notably

prototype models including most notably abyss creations the makers of something

abyss creations the makers of something

abyss creations the makers of something called the real doll who are planning to

called the real doll who are planning to

called the real doll who are planning to launch a prototype sex robot in the

launch a prototype sex robot in the

launch a prototype sex robot in the latter part of this year so I’m a legal

latter part of this year so I’m a legal

latter part of this year so I’m a legal academic and ethicist with an interest

academic and ethicist with an interest

academic and ethicist with an interest in the social legal and ethical

in the social legal and ethical

in the social legal and ethical implications of this technology I want

implications of this technology I want

implications of this technology I want to talk to you about some of those

to talk to you about some of those

to talk to you about some of those implications today

implications today

implications today now I titled my talk symbols and their

now I titled my talk symbols and their

now I titled my talk symbols and their consequences in the sex robot debate and

consequences in the sex robot debate and

consequences in the sex robot debate and that’s a title that I think probably

that’s a title that I think probably

that’s a title that I think probably prompts a number of questions one of the

prompts a number of questions one of the

prompts a number of questions one of the most obvious questions is is there

most obvious questions is is there

most obvious questions is is there actually a debate about this topic in

actually a debate about this topic in

actually a debate about this topic in academia and there is and when I talk to

academia and there is and when I talk to

academia and there is and when I talk to my colleagues about my interest in this

my colleagues about my interest in this

my colleagues about my interest in this topic they usually treat me with a

topic they usually treat me with a

topic they usually treat me with a mixture of derision and bemusement but

mixture of derision and bemusement but

mixture of derision and bemusement but there are some people who research this

there are some people who research this

there are some people who research this we take the topic very seriously indeed

we take the topic very seriously indeed

we take the topic very seriously indeed and probably the most notable example of

and probably the most notable example of

and probably the most notable example of that is Cathleen Richardson who’s a

that is Cathleen Richardson who’s a

that is Cathleen Richardson who’s a senior research fellow at De Montfort

senior research fellow at De Montfort

senior research fellow at De Montfort University in Leicester in the UK who in

University in Leicester in the UK who in

University in Leicester in the UK who in September 2015

September 2015

September 2015 launched something called the campaign

launched something called the campaign

launched something called the campaign against sex robots this was modeled on a

against sex robots this was modeled on a

against sex robots this was modeled on a much longer standing campaign against

much longer standing campaign against

much longer standing campaign against killer robots which tries to

killer robots which tries to

killer robots which tries to preemptively ban autonomous weapons and

preemptively ban autonomous weapons and

preemptively ban autonomous weapons and Kathleen Richardson submitted that the

Kathleen Richardson submitted that the

Kathleen Richardson submitted that the social consequences in harm that might

social consequences in harm that might

social consequences in harm that might arise from the creation of this

arise from the creation of this

arise from the creation of this technology were sufficiently serious to

technology were sufficiently serious to

technology were sufficiently serious to warrant an organized campaign against

warrant an organized campaign against

warrant an organized campaign against their development so what I want to

their development so what I want to

their development so what I want to consider in the remainder of the time

consider in the remainder of the time

consider in the remainder of the time that I have is whether this kind of

that I have is whether this kind of

that I have is whether this kind of organized opposition to this technology

organized opposition to this technology

organized opposition to this technology is something that we should take

is something that we should take

is something that we should take seriously or not and I’ll do so by

seriously or not and I’ll do so by

seriously or not and I’ll do so by discussing what I take to be the leading

discussing what I take to be the leading

discussing what I take to be the leading kind of objection to the development of

kind of objection to the development of

kind of objection to the development of this technology something that I call

this technology something that I call

this technology something that I call the symbolic consequences argument and

the symbolic consequences argument and

the symbolic consequences argument and I’ll try and explain what that argument

I’ll try and explain what that argument

I’ll try and explain what that argument is by way of an example or a story so

is by way of an example or a story so

is by way of an example or a story so don’t know if anyone here has ever seen

don’t know if anyone here has ever seen

don’t know if anyone here has ever seen the channel 4 TV series humans these are

the channel 4 TV series humans these are

the channel 4 TV series humans these are some of the actors from the TV show this

some of the actors from the TV show this

some of the actors from the TV show this was the only image I could find that was

was the only image I could find that was

was the only image I could find that was in the public domain so that’s why I’m

in the public domain so that’s why I’m

in the public domain so that’s why I’m showing it and the show depicts a near

showing it and the show depicts a near

showing it and the show depicts a near human future consisting of social robots

human future consisting of social robots

human future consisting of social robots they’re ubiquitous people use them in

they’re ubiquitous people use them in

they’re ubiquitous people use them in their homes and work as helpers and

their homes and work as helpers and

their homes and work as helpers and carers and also

carers and also

carers and also as sexual playthings the robots in the

as sexual playthings the robots in the

as sexual playthings the robots in the TV series don’t have human level

TV series don’t have human level

TV series don’t have human level consciousness or awareness although the

consciousness or awareness although the

consciousness or awareness although the main plotline does revolve around a

main plotline does revolve around a

main plotline does revolve around a group of five robots that seem to have

group of five robots that seem to have

group of five robots that seem to have achieved that level of consciousness and

achieved that level of consciousness and

achieved that level of consciousness and awareness and in one episode of this

awareness and in one episode of this

awareness and in one episode of this show there’s a house party taking place

show there’s a house party taking place

show there’s a house party taking place the group of teenagers there’s a robot

the group of teenagers there’s a robot

the group of teenagers there’s a robot at the house party who looks like a

at the house party who looks like a

at the house party who looks like a female woman and and she’s serving them

female woman and and she’s serving them

female woman and and she’s serving them drinks and she’s cleaning up after them

drinks and she’s cleaning up after them

drinks and she’s cleaning up after them at one point during the party a group of

at one point during the party a group of

at one point during the party a group of young men started hurling abuse at the

young men started hurling abuse at the

young men started hurling abuse at the robot one of them switches her off he

robot one of them switches her off he

robot one of them switches her off he tells his friends and he’s going to drag

tells his friends and he’s going to drag

tells his friends and he’s going to drag her upstairs and have sex with her at

her upstairs and have sex with her at

her upstairs and have sex with her at this point one of the female

this point one of the female

this point one of the female protagonists in the show intervenes and

protagonists in the show intervenes and

protagonists in the show intervenes and says that tells him to stop and says and

says that tells him to stop and says and

says that tells him to stop and says and would you do that to a real woman okay

would you do that to a real woman okay

would you do that to a real woman okay so at this point the show creators don’t

so at this point the show creators don’t

so at this point the show creators don’t stop and tell us what the logic or

stop and tell us what the logic or

stop and tell us what the logic or principles underlying that objection

principles underlying that objection

principles underlying that objection were like all good fiction writers

were like all good fiction writers

were like all good fiction writers they’ve learned to show and not tell but

they’ve learned to show and not tell but

they’ve learned to show and not tell but I’m interested in the telling I’m

I’m interested in the telling I’m

I’m interested in the telling I’m interested in what the logic of this

interested in what the logic of this

interested in what the logic of this objection is because on the face of it

objection is because on the face of it

objection is because on the face of it there’s something of a puzzle the robots

there’s something of a puzzle the robots

there’s something of a puzzle the robots in the show lack consciousness and

in the show lack consciousness and

in the show lack consciousness and awareness so they can’t be harmed by

awareness so they can’t be harmed by

awareness so they can’t be harmed by anything that we do to them and as an

anything that we do to them and as an

anything that we do to them and as an aside this is an assumption that most

aside this is an assumption that most

aside this is an assumption that most people within the sex robot debate

people within the sex robot debate

people within the sex robot debate assume will be true for the foreseeable

assume will be true for the foreseeable

assume will be true for the foreseeable future

future

future that robots will lack consciousness and

that robots will lack consciousness and

that robots will lack consciousness and awareness we may create such robots one

awareness we may create such robots one

awareness we may create such robots one day but it’s a long way off so if we

day but it’s a long way off so if we

day but it’s a long way off so if we can’t harm them why is it objectionable

can’t harm them why is it objectionable

can’t harm them why is it objectionable to do anything to them and I think the

to do anything to them and I think the

to do anything to them and I think the answer to that must lie in the symbolism

answer to that must lie in the symbolism

answer to that must lie in the symbolism of the act or of the robots themselves

of the act or of the robots themselves

of the act or of the robots themselves what they say about our attitudes –

what they say about our attitudes –

what they say about our attitudes – towards real human women for example or

towards real human women for example or

towards real human women for example or in the or and additionally in the

in the or and additionally in the

in the or and additionally in the consequences of the act and this concern

consequences of the act and this concern

consequences of the act and this concern for symbols and their consequences is

for symbols and their consequences is

for symbols and their consequences is something that is shared by most of the

something that is shared by most of the

something that is shared by most of the opponents to this technology and their

opponents to this technology and their

opponents to this technology and their objection can be phrased as simple

objection can be phrased as simple

objection can be phrased as simple logical argument and since I’m an

logical argument and since I’m an

logical argument and since I’m an academic this is the form of expression

academic this is the form of expression

academic this is the form of expression that I like so I’ll try and share that

that I like so I’ll try and share that

that I like so I’ll try and share that argument with you now it has two

argument with you now it has two

argument with you now it has two premises and a conclusion the first

premises and a conclusion the first

premises and a conclusion the first premise focuses on the negative symbol

premise focuses on the negative symbol

premise focuses on the negative symbol is

is

is sex robots what they represent and what

sex robots what they represent and what

sex robots what they represent and what the act of having sex with them

the act of having sex with them

the act of having sex with them represents that it represents something

represents that it represents something

represents that it represents something ethically problematic about our attitude

ethically problematic about our attitude

ethically problematic about our attitude towards sexual norms or gender equality

towards sexual norms or gender equality

towards sexual norms or gender equality and things like that so it’s a symbolic

and things like that so it’s a symbolic

and things like that so it’s a symbolic acclaim the second premise then is that

acclaim the second premise then is that

acclaim the second premise then is that if they have this negative symbolism or

if they have this negative symbolism or

if they have this negative symbolism or negative meaning they will also have

negative meaning they will also have

negative meaning they will also have negative consequences for society

negative consequences for society

negative consequences for society that’s the consequential claim and then

that’s the consequential claim and then

that’s the consequential claim and then the conclusion that we is drawn from

the conclusion that we is drawn from

the conclusion that we is drawn from this by people like Cathleen Richardson

this by people like Cathleen Richardson

this by people like Cathleen Richardson is that this means we should probably do

is that this means we should probably do

is that this means we should probably do something about it that the creation of

something about it that the creation of

something about it that the creation of these robots will have negative

these robots will have negative

these robots will have negative consequences and we should do something

consequences and we should do something

consequences and we should do something to avoid or prohibit their creation so

to avoid or prohibit their creation so

to avoid or prohibit their creation so this is just an abstract argument that

this is just an abstract argument that

this is just an abstract argument that kind of templates that people fill out

kind of templates that people fill out

kind of templates that people fill out with specific examples of negative

with specific examples of negative

with specific examples of negative meaning and negative consequences and

meaning and negative consequences and

meaning and negative consequences and just to show you how people do this I’ll

just to show you how people do this I’ll

just to show you how people do this I’ll give you two examples from the academic

give you two examples from the academic

give you two examples from the academic literature of negative symbolism and

literature of negative symbolism and

literature of negative symbolism and negative consequences the first comes

negative consequences the first comes

negative consequences the first comes from Cynthiana GU – she’s a Canadian

from Cynthiana GU – she’s a Canadian

from Cynthiana GU – she’s a Canadian lawyer who a few years ago wrote an

lawyer who a few years ago wrote an

lawyer who a few years ago wrote an article called the robot cessation of

article called the robot cessation of

article called the robot cessation of consent and her concern was particularly

consent and her concern was particularly

consent and her concern was particularly for the way in which robots represented

for the way in which robots represented

for the way in which robots represented women and just another aside here

women and just another aside here

women and just another aside here presumably one day we will create robots

presumably one day we will create robots

presumably one day we will create robots sex robots that represent men or the

sex robots that represent men or the

sex robots that represent men or the cater to transgender markets and in fact

cater to transgender markets and in fact

cater to transgender markets and in fact the makers of real dolls say that this

the makers of real dolls say that this

the makers of real dolls say that this is something they want to do but there’s

is something they want to do but there’s

is something they want to do but there’s little point in denying that for the

little point in denying that for the

little point in denying that for the foreseeable future

foreseeable future

foreseeable future these robots tend to be marketed as

these robots tend to be marketed as

these robots tend to be marketed as heterosexual men okay so GU to you was

heterosexual men okay so GU to you was

heterosexual men okay so GU to you was concerned about the way in which they

concerned about the way in which they

concerned about the way in which they represented women I’ll just give you an

represented women I’ll just give you an

represented women I’ll just give you an example of one of the robots she

example of one of the robots she

example of one of the robots she discussed in her paper this is a robot

discussed in her paper this is a robot

discussed in her paper this is a robot called repla aq2 it’s not designed for

called repla aq2 it’s not designed for

called repla aq2 it’s not designed for sexual purposes but you can see the kind

sexual purposes but you can see the kind

sexual purposes but you can see the kind of representation it has and in her

of representation it has and in her

of representation it has and in her paper she comes to how love these robots

paper she comes to how love these robots

paper she comes to how love these robots are thin attractive oriental women with

are thin attractive oriental women with

are thin attractive oriental women with high-pitched voices feminine and

high-pitched voices feminine and

high-pitched voices feminine and movements and they often wear these kind

movements and they often wear these kind

movements and they often wear these kind of provocative clothing so she thinks

of provocative clothing so she thinks

of provocative clothing so she thinks this is kind of reinforcing negative

this is kind of reinforcing negative

this is kind of reinforcing negative stereotypes or norms of beauty and she

stereotypes or norms of beauty and she

stereotypes or norms of beauty and she also worries then about the symbolism of

also worries then about the symbolism of

also worries then about the symbolism of having sex with such an object

having sex with such an object

having sex with such an object and so far as it represents women as

and so far as it represents women as

and so far as it represents women as these passive ever consenting sexual

these passive ever consenting sexual

these passive ever consenting sexual objects or tools and she’s then says in

objects or tools and she’s then says in

objects or tools and she’s then says in her paper that this will have maybe two

her paper that this will have maybe two

her paper that this will have maybe two negative consequences one is that a

negative consequences one is that a

negative consequences one is that a little it will encourage young men to

little it will encourage young men to

little it will encourage young men to treat women as sexual objects or else

treat women as sexual objects or else

treat women as sexual objects or else alternatively that it will encourage

alternatively that it will encourage

alternatively that it will encourage them to withdraw from society and become

them to withdraw from society and become

them to withdraw from society and become more isolated and misanthropic in their

more isolated and misanthropic in their

more isolated and misanthropic in their views that’s one example of his combined

views that’s one example of his combined

views that’s one example of his combined concern for symbolism and its

concern for symbolism and its

concern for symbolism and its consequences another example comes from

consequences another example comes from

consequences another example comes from the aforementioned Kathleen Richardson

the aforementioned Kathleen Richardson

the aforementioned Kathleen Richardson so in her paper on kind of launching the

so in her paper on kind of launching the

so in her paper on kind of launching the campaign against sex robots she argued

campaign against sex robots she argued

campaign against sex robots she argued that most of these robots are being

that most of these robots are being

that most of these robots are being created with at the model of

created with at the model of

created with at the model of prostitution or sex work in mind said

prostitution or sex work in mind said

prostitution or sex work in mind said that the developers of these robots want

that the developers of these robots want

that the developers of these robots want to create a an artificial facsimile of

to create a an artificial facsimile of

to create a an artificial facsimile of the kind of interaction that a client

the kind of interaction that a client

the kind of interaction that a client gets with a sex worker

gets with a sex worker

gets with a sex worker so she focuses for example in the work

so she focuses for example in the work

so she focuses for example in the work of David Levy who wrote a book back in

of David Levy who wrote a book back in

of David Levy who wrote a book back in 2007 called love and sex with robots

2007 called love and sex with robots

2007 called love and sex with robots about the future of romantic

about the future of romantic

about the future of romantic relationships with artificial objects

relationships with artificial objects

relationships with artificial objects and he explicitly modeled the

and he explicitly modeled the

and he explicitly modeled the development of these robots on the kind

development of these robots on the kind

development of these robots on the kind of relationship between a prostitute and

of relationship between a prostitute and

of relationship between a prostitute and a client so this is problematic for

a client so this is problematic for

a client so this is problematic for Richardson because that relationship is

Richardson because that relationship is

Richardson because that relationship is promised on a symmetries of power where

promised on a symmetries of power where

promised on a symmetries of power where the client has all the power and treats

the client has all the power and treats

the client has all the power and treats the sex worker as an object and so the

the sex worker as an object and so the

the sex worker as an object and so the creation of these robots just symbolizes

creation of these robots just symbolizes

creation of these robots just symbolizes that style of relationship and this will

that style of relationship and this will

that style of relationship and this will again have negative consequences because

again have negative consequences because

again have negative consequences because it will she says in this quote

it will she says in this quote

it will she says in this quote legitamate a dangerous mode of existence

legitamate a dangerous mode of existence

legitamate a dangerous mode of existence where humans can move about in relations

where humans can move about in relations

where humans can move about in relations with other humans but not recognize them

with other humans but not recognize them

with other humans but not recognize them as human subjects in their own right

as human subjects in their own right

as human subjects in their own right okay so that’s two examples of this

okay so that’s two examples of this

okay so that’s two examples of this symbolic consequences argument in the

symbolic consequences argument in the

symbolic consequences argument in the sex robot debate so is this argument any

sex robot debate so is this argument any

sex robot debate so is this argument any good is this something that we should

good is this something that we should

good is this something that we should take seriously I certainly think that

take seriously I certainly think that

take seriously I certainly think that the proponents of these arguments have

the proponents of these arguments have

the proponents of these arguments have raised legitimate concerns or fears that

raised legitimate concerns or fears that

raised legitimate concerns or fears that you could have but the development of

you could have but the development of

you could have but the development of this technology but I want to close by

this technology but I want to close by

this technology but I want to close by defending our put forward two

defending our put forward two

defending our put forward two propositions that call their argument

propositions that call their argument

propositions that call their argument into doubt okay so the first profit

into doubt okay so the first profit

into doubt okay so the first profit position that I want to defend is that

position that I want to defend is that

position that I want to defend is that the symbolic meaning of anything of any

the symbolic meaning of anything of any

the symbolic meaning of anything of any representation or practice is highly

representation or practice is highly

representation or practice is highly contingent and this has important

contingent and this has important

contingent and this has important implications for how we approach the sex

implications for how we approach the sex

implications for how we approach the sex robot debate so some classic examples of

robot debate so some classic examples of

robot debate so some classic examples of this relate to the ways in which

this relate to the ways in which

this relate to the ways in which different human cultures treat had the

different human cultures treat had the

different human cultures treat had the bodies of the dead so most cultures

bodies of the dead so most cultures

bodies of the dead so most cultures agree that you have to show respect for

agree that you have to show respect for

agree that you have to show respect for the bodies of the dead but they disagree

the bodies of the dead but they disagree

the bodies of the dead but they disagree upon the symbolic act that best

upon the symbolic act that best

upon the symbolic act that best demonstrates respect a famous

demonstrates respect a famous

demonstrates respect a famous illustration of this comes from

illustration of this comes from

illustration of this comes from Herodotus as histories where he

Herodotus as histories where he

Herodotus as histories where he contrasts the burial practices of the

contrasts the burial practices of the

contrasts the burial practices of the Greeks and the collations so the story

Greeks and the collations so the story

Greeks and the collations so the story goes that King Darius of Persia once

goes that King Darius of Persia once

goes that King Darius of Persia once asked the Greeks what’s the appropriate

asked the Greeks what’s the appropriate

asked the Greeks what’s the appropriate way to show respect for the bodies of

way to show respect for the bodies of

way to show respect for the bodies of the dead and they said that the

the dead and they said that the

the dead and they said that the appropriate way to show respect was to

appropriate way to show respect was to

appropriate way to show respect was to burn the bodies on a funeral pyre that’s

burn the bodies on a funeral pyre that’s

burn the bodies on a funeral pyre that’s what’s being depicted in this scene here

what’s being depicted in this scene here

what’s being depicted in this scene here then he went to the collations he said

then he went to the collations he said

then he went to the collations he said how do you show respect to the bodies of

how do you show respect to the bodies of

how do you show respect to the bodies of the dead do you burn them on a funeral

the dead do you burn them on a funeral

the dead do you burn them on a funeral pyre and they said absolutely not what

pyre and they said absolutely not what

pyre and they said absolutely not what you that would be to treat them like a

you that would be to treat them like a

you that would be to treat them like a piece of trash or a piece of rubbish the

piece of trash or a piece of rubbish the

piece of trash or a piece of rubbish the way in which to show respect is to eat

way in which to show respect is to eat

way in which to show respect is to eat the bodies of the Dead and the Greeks

the bodies of the Dead and the Greeks

the bodies of the Dead and the Greeks founded this of course abhorrent there’s

founded this of course abhorrent there’s

founded this of course abhorrent there’s something interesting here in this

something interesting here in this

something interesting here in this example you have agreement on what the

example you have agreement on what the

example you have agreement on what the symbolic practice should do but in one

symbolic practice should do but in one

symbolic practice should do but in one culture as symbolic practice has a

culture as symbolic practice has a

culture as symbolic practice has a negative meaning and in the other

negative meaning and in the other

negative meaning and in the other culture it has a positive meaning and

culture it has a positive meaning and

culture it has a positive meaning and vice-versa once you have this cultural

vice-versa once you have this cultural

vice-versa once you have this cultural or social contingency and of the meaning

or social contingency and of the meaning

or social contingency and of the meaning of a practice and this then has

of a practice and this then has

of a practice and this then has important repercussions for how we

important repercussions for how we

important repercussions for how we approach any argument that focuses on

approach any argument that focuses on

approach any argument that focuses on the symbolism of an object or a practice

the symbolism of an object or a practice

the symbolism of an object or a practice it means that we can’t treat the meaning

it means that we can’t treat the meaning

it means that we can’t treat the meaning that we attach to the symbolism as

that we attach to the symbolism as

that we attach to the symbolism as something that is fixed that’s given

something that is fixed that’s given

something that is fixed that’s given that we just have to live with it’s

that we just have to live with it’s

that we just have to live with it’s possible for us to change the meaning of

possible for us to change the meaning of

possible for us to change the meaning of a practice and in certain circumstances

a practice and in certain circumstances

a practice and in certain circumstances we probably should do that so to give an

we probably should do that so to give an

we probably should do that so to give an example of this the philosophers Jason

example of this the philosophers Jason

example of this the philosophers Jason Brennan and Peter Jaworski have looked

Brennan and Peter Jaworski have looked

Brennan and Peter Jaworski have looked at the meaning that is attached to

at the meaning that is attached to

at the meaning that is attached to commodified relationships and practices

commodified relationships and practices

commodified relationships and practices and they use an example based on burial

and they use an example based on burial

and they use an example based on burial practices as well to show

practices as well to show

practices as well to show the circumstances in which we ought to

the circumstances in which we ought to

the circumstances in which we ought to change the meaning that attaches to a

change the meaning that attaches to a

change the meaning that attaches to a symbolic ritual and the example they use

symbolic ritual and the example they use

symbolic ritual and the example they use is of the for a tribe in Papua New

is of the for a tribe in Papua New

is of the for a tribe in Papua New Guinea who like the collations used to

Guinea who like the collations used to

Guinea who like the collations used to think that the appropriate way to

think that the appropriate way to

think that the appropriate way to respect the bodies of the dead was to

respect the bodies of the dead was to

respect the bodies of the dead was to eat them until it was discovered that

eat them until it was discovered that

eat them until it was discovered that this practice may cause a disease a

this practice may cause a disease a

this practice may cause a disease a prion disease and so the practice was

prion disease and so the practice was

prion disease and so the practice was outlawed and what used to be a positive

outlawed and what used to be a positive

outlawed and what used to be a positive symbolic ritual became a negative

symbolic ritual became a negative

symbolic ritual became a negative symbolic ritual so you have a case here

symbolic ritual so you have a case here

symbolic ritual so you have a case here in which something that had a positive

in which something that had a positive

in which something that had a positive meaning changed its meaning because it

meaning changed its meaning because it

meaning changed its meaning because it had a negative consequence and the same

had a negative consequence and the same

had a negative consequence and the same thing can happen in Reverse if we have

thing can happen in Reverse if we have

thing can happen in Reverse if we have something that has a negative meaning

something that has a negative meaning

something that has a negative meaning but it’s shown to have positive

but it’s shown to have positive

but it’s shown to have positive consequences then maybe what we ought to

consequences then maybe what we ought to

consequences then maybe what we ought to do is change the meaning that attaches

do is change the meaning that attaches

do is change the meaning that attaches to the ritual or symbolism itself so

to the ritual or symbolism itself so

to the ritual or symbolism itself so that means that in the sex robot debate

that means that in the sex robot debate

that means that in the sex robot debate consequences become all-important what

consequences become all-important what

consequences become all-important what are the actual consequence is going to

are the actual consequence is going to

are the actual consequence is going to be of developing this technology if

be of developing this technology if

be of developing this technology if Richardson and Goethe are correct then

Richardson and Goethe are correct then

Richardson and Goethe are correct then maybe we should indeed prohibit or

maybe we should indeed prohibit or

maybe we should indeed prohibit or regulate the development of this

regulate the development of this

regulate the development of this technology it has a negative meaning and

technology it has a negative meaning and

technology it has a negative meaning and a negative consequence if on the other

a negative consequence if on the other

a negative consequence if on the other hand proponents of the technology like

hand proponents of the technology like

hand proponents of the technology like David Levy are correct it’ll have

David Levy are correct it’ll have

David Levy are correct it’ll have positive consequences which means maybe

positive consequences which means maybe

positive consequences which means maybe we ought to change the negative meaning

we ought to change the negative meaning

we ought to change the negative meaning that attaches to it

that attaches to it

that attaches to it but that’s where my second proposition

but that’s where my second proposition

but that’s where my second proposition comes into play I think that the

comes into play I think that the

comes into play I think that the consequences of developing this

consequences of developing this

consequences of developing this technology are likely to be highly

technology are likely to be highly

technology are likely to be highly contentious or uncertain it’s going to

contentious or uncertain it’s going to

contentious or uncertain it’s going to be very difficult to know for sure

be very difficult to know for sure

be very difficult to know for sure whether it has a positive or negative

whether it has a positive or negative

whether it has a positive or negative consequence for society as a whole now

consequence for society as a whole now

consequence for society as a whole now why do I say this

why do I say this

why do I say this well obviously we don’t have any good

well obviously we don’t have any good

well obviously we don’t have any good information about what its consequences

information about what its consequences

information about what its consequences will be this is a technology that’s in

will be this is a technology that’s in

will be this is a technology that’s in infancy there’s no empirical studies

infancy there’s no empirical studies

infancy there’s no empirical studies that I’m aware of that have been

that I’m aware of that have been

that I’m aware of that have been performed about its implications for

performed about its implications for

performed about its implications for society but we do have analogous debates

society but we do have analogous debates

society but we do have analogous debates which give us some hint at what the

which give us some hint at what the

which give us some hint at what the possibilities will be and in fact if we

possibilities will be and in fact if we

possibilities will be and in fact if we are to follow Richardson and

are to follow Richardson and

are to follow Richardson and prohibitively campaign or say

prohibitively campaign or say

prohibitively campaign or say preemptively campaign against this

preemptively campaign against this

preemptively campaign against this technology then we can only rely on

technology then we can only rely on

technology then we can only rely on these analogies and one classic analogy

these analogies and one classic analogy

these analogies and one classic analogy here would be with the debate about the

here would be with the debate about the

here would be with the debate about the exposure to pornography okay so for the

exposure to pornography okay so for the

exposure to pornography okay so for the past 30 or 40 years a debate has been

past 30 or 40 years a debate has been

past 30 or 40 years a debate has been raging about whether exposure to

raging about whether exposure to

raging about whether exposure to pornography has negative or positive

pornography has negative or positive

pornography has negative or positive consequences for society according to

consequences for society according to

consequences for society according to one recent survey that I read is about

one recent survey that I read is about

one recent survey that I read is about 40,000 studies that have been performed

40,000 studies that have been performed

40,000 studies that have been performed on this question and if you read those

on this question and if you read those

on this question and if you read those studies you’ll find many that show that

studies you’ll find many that show that

studies you’ll find many that show that there is a negative consequence you’ll

there is a negative consequence you’ll

there is a negative consequence you’ll find many that show that there is no

find many that show that there is no

find many that show that there is no consequence at all they also find many

consequence at all they also find many

consequence at all they also find many that show that there’s a positive

that show that there’s a positive

that show that there’s a positive consequence and most of the researchers

consequence and most of the researchers

consequence and most of the researchers in this field lament the poor quality of

in this field lament the poor quality of

in this field lament the poor quality of the evidence that we have but it can’t

the evidence that we have but it can’t

the evidence that we have but it can’t decisively answer this question so I

decisively answer this question so I

decisively answer this question so I think when it comes to the development

think when it comes to the development

think when it comes to the development of sex robots the same thing is going to

of sex robots the same thing is going to

of sex robots the same thing is going to be true we’re unlikely to know what the

be true we’re unlikely to know what the

be true we’re unlikely to know what the consequences will be so it leaves us

consequences will be so it leaves us

consequences will be so it leaves us standing in a very uncertain position

standing in a very uncertain position

standing in a very uncertain position we’re facing into an uncertain future

we’re facing into an uncertain future

we’re facing into an uncertain future with this technology and when we face

with this technology and when we face

with this technology and when we face into an uncertain future we have some

into an uncertain future we have some

into an uncertain future we have some options and I think that the main option

options and I think that the main option

options and I think that the main option would be to fall back on a commitment to

would be to fall back on a commitment to

would be to fall back on a commitment to some kind of fundamental value so either

some kind of fundamental value so either

some kind of fundamental value so either we embrace Liberty let’s say and think

we embrace Liberty let’s say and think

we embrace Liberty let’s say and think that people should develop this

that people should develop this

that people should develop this technology freely or we embrace

technology freely or we embrace

technology freely or we embrace uncertainty and think that people should

uncertainty and think that people should

uncertainty and think that people should be allowed to experiment with the

be allowed to experiment with the

be allowed to experiment with the technology but we should monitor it

technology but we should monitor it

technology but we should monitor it closely at all times or else we could be

closely at all times or else we could be

closely at all times or else we could be highly precautionary in our approach if

highly precautionary in our approach if

highly precautionary in our approach if there’s any possible risk at all we

there’s any possible risk at all we

there’s any possible risk at all we should just avoid developing it either

should just avoid developing it either

should just avoid developing it either way though I think that focusing on the

way though I think that focusing on the

way though I think that focusing on the symbolic meaning and the consequences of

symbolic meaning and the consequences of

symbolic meaning and the consequences of that symbolic meaning is not the way to

that symbolic meaning is not the way to

that symbolic meaning is not the way to go thank you

go thank you

go thank you [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *