Press "Enter" to skip to content

High vs. Low Art | Alex Urasaki | TEDxCardinalNewmanHS


[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

[Music]

[Music] so the reputation that things have in

so the reputation that things have in

so the reputation that things have in society often change the way that we

society often change the way that we

society often change the way that we perceive them and the art world is no

perceive them and the art world is no

perceive them and the art world is no different in the art world if something

different in the art world if something

different in the art world if something is considered high art versus low art it

is considered high art versus low art it

is considered high art versus low art it will often change the way that we

will often change the way that we

will often change the way that we perceive that piece hi my name is

perceive that piece hi my name is

perceive that piece hi my name is Alexander your sake and today I’ll be

Alexander your sake and today I’ll be

Alexander your sake and today I’ll be discussing this division between high

discussing this division between high

discussing this division between high and low art the validity to this line

and low art the validity to this line

and low art the validity to this line that separates them and finally the

that separates them and finally the

that separates them and finally the damage that this line can create so yeah

damage that this line can create so yeah

damage that this line can create so yeah high versus low art I thought I’d keep

high versus low art I thought I’d keep

high versus low art I thought I’d keep my title nice and simple but if it’s not

my title nice and simple but if it’s not

my title nice and simple but if it’s not like a paragraph it’s not with a title

like a paragraph it’s not with a title

like a paragraph it’s not with a title so yeah art I didn’t really start doing

so yeah art I didn’t really start doing

so yeah art I didn’t really start doing art until the 8th grade don’t get me

art until the 8th grade don’t get me

art until the 8th grade don’t get me wrong

wrong

wrong our was a class you know I’d go in there

our was a class you know I’d go in there

our was a class you know I’d go in there draw Pokemon but then 45 minutes later

draw Pokemon but then 45 minutes later

draw Pokemon but then 45 minutes later I’d leave and outside of that 45 minutes

I’d leave and outside of that 45 minutes

I’d leave and outside of that 45 minutes I didn’t spend any time really thinking

I didn’t spend any time really thinking

I didn’t spend any time really thinking about art I was in doing art I didn’t

about art I was in doing art I didn’t

about art I was in doing art I didn’t look at art I didn’t really even doodle

look at art I didn’t really even doodle

look at art I didn’t really even doodle however this all changed in like the

however this all changed in like the

however this all changed in like the second half of eighth grade and it had

second half of eighth grade and it had

second half of eighth grade and it had to do actually with a girl I like this

to do actually with a girl I like this

to do actually with a girl I like this girl except the problem was that she

girl except the problem was that she

girl except the problem was that she didn’t like me back she liked this other

didn’t like me back she liked this other

didn’t like me back she liked this other guy but you know he’s a cool guy like I

guy but you know he’s a cool guy like I

guy but you know he’s a cool guy like I can’t really blame her but then he

can’t really blame her but then he

can’t really blame her but then he didn’t like her back he actually liked

didn’t like her back he actually liked

didn’t like her back he actually liked this other girl yeah it was crazy I

this other girl yeah it was crazy I

this other girl yeah it was crazy I didn’t like this girl though but it was

didn’t like this girl though but it was

didn’t like this girl though but it was even more complicated because she was

even more complicated because she was

even more complicated because she was like best friends with the girl they

like best friends with the girl they

like best friends with the girl they liked so it’s confusing but anyway long

liked so it’s confusing but anyway long

liked so it’s confusing but anyway long story short I needed a way to impress

story short I needed a way to impress

story short I needed a way to impress this girl that I liked so I thought

this girl that I liked so I thought

this girl that I liked so I thought what’s something I haven’t tried let’s

what’s something I haven’t tried let’s

what’s something I haven’t tried let’s try art so so yes that’s what I did so I

try art so so yes that’s what I did so I

try art so so yes that’s what I did so I did I started doing this is the first

did I started doing this is the first

did I started doing this is the first actually work of art that I did that was

actually work of art that I did that was

actually work of art that I did that was like kind of outside of this class

like kind of outside of this class

like kind of outside of this class something I was interested in and I did

something I was interested in and I did

something I was interested in and I did art that I thought was cool because then

art that I thought was cool because then

art that I thought was cool because then maybe she thinks that it was cool too so

maybe she thinks that it was cool too so

maybe she thinks that it was cool too so fast forward a couple of years never got

fast forward a couple of years never got

fast forward a couple of years never got the girl so

the girl so

the girl so ladies I’m available but I did get I did

ladies I’m available but I did get I did

ladies I’m available but I did get I did get pretty good at art I started doing

get pretty good at art I started doing

get pretty good at art I started doing things like this and like this which is

things like this and like this which is

things like this and like this which is actually about eight feet tall and it

actually about eight feet tall and it

actually about eight feet tall and it was the backdrop for a play and I did it

was the backdrop for a play and I did it

was the backdrop for a play and I did it with spray paint and as I got better at

with spray paint and as I got better at

with spray paint and as I got better at doing art people started calling me an

doing art people started calling me an

doing art people started calling me an artist and with that comes a whole bunch

artist and with that comes a whole bunch

artist and with that comes a whole bunch of questions from family and friends but

of questions from family and friends but

of questions from family and friends but also from myself questions for my

also from myself questions for my

also from myself questions for my parents like this art thing we keep

parents like this art thing we keep

parents like this art thing we keep doing it which is not always the best

doing it which is not always the best

doing it which is not always the best response you want when you tell someone

response you want when you tell someone

response you want when you tell someone your passion but or other questions like

your passion but or other questions like

your passion but or other questions like questions from my grandma for concern

questions from my grandma for concern

questions from my grandma for concern for my mental health and how is going to

for my mental health and how is going to

for my mental health and how is going to make money doing art which I had to

make money doing art which I had to

make money doing art which I had to respond to you by saying grandma I’m not

respond to you by saying grandma I’m not

respond to you by saying grandma I’m not crazy

crazy

crazy and I have like 42 bucks you know how

and I have like 42 bucks you know how

and I have like 42 bucks you know how you talk to your grandma but I actually

you talk to your grandma but I actually

you talk to your grandma but I actually look this up and I found there’s three

look this up and I found there’s three

look this up and I found there’s three stages of reaction it starts in denial a

stages of reaction it starts in denial a

stages of reaction it starts in denial a concern and I instigate through the

concern and I instigate through the

concern and I instigate through the whole class but the final stage I think

whole class but the final stage I think

whole class but the final stage I think is depression so wish me luck eventually

is depression so wish me luck eventually

is depression so wish me luck eventually I’ll get everybody there and then like I

I’ll get everybody there and then like I

I’ll get everybody there and then like I said before there’s also questions I for

said before there’s also questions I for

said before there’s also questions I for myself

myself

myself because as you start looking at art and

because as you start looking at art and

because as you start looking at art and going to galleries it’s kind of

going to galleries it’s kind of

going to galleries it’s kind of confusing sometimes and so when I would

confusing sometimes and so when I would

confusing sometimes and so when I would go to galleries I could say I like this

go to galleries I could say I like this

go to galleries I could say I like this painting this painting is good I like

painting this painting is good I like

painting this painting is good I like the color in it but as soon as people

the color in it but as soon as people

the color in it but as soon as people start throwing around words like

start throwing around words like

start throwing around words like courageous

courageous

courageous I felt like intimidated I felt that what

I felt like intimidated I felt that what

I felt like intimidated I felt that what they were seeing they were smarter than

they were seeing they were smarter than

they were seeing they were smarter than me and what they were observing in this

me and what they were observing in this

me and what they were observing in this art was over my head however with this

art was over my head however with this

art was over my head however with this feeling of intimidation also came a

feeling of intimidation also came a

feeling of intimidation also came a question for myself how come people in a

question for myself how come people in a

question for myself how come people in a gallery will spend millions of dollars

gallery will spend millions of dollars

gallery will spend millions of dollars on art on a piece of art however the

on art on a piece of art however the

on art on a piece of art however the street art done outside on the parking

street art done outside on the parking

street art done outside on the parking garage is being washed off the wall by

garage is being washed off the wall by

garage is being washed off the wall by some dude named Doug don’t don’t get me

some dude named Doug don’t don’t get me

some dude named Doug don’t don’t get me wrong

wrong

wrong Doug’s a great guy civil servant he’s

Doug’s a great guy civil servant he’s

Doug’s a great guy civil servant he’s great with kids he jogs but nonetheless

great with kids he jogs but nonetheless

great with kids he jogs but nonetheless it’s illegal it’s a

it’s illegal it’s a

it’s illegal it’s a it’s worthless right it’s low art and I

it’s worthless right it’s low art and I

it’s worthless right it’s low art and I didn’t realize at the time that this was

didn’t realize at the time that this was

didn’t realize at the time that this was my question of low versus high art high

my question of low versus high art high

my question of low versus high art high art being the gallery art low art being

art being the gallery art low art being

art being the gallery art low art being the street art and even then it was like

the street art and even then it was like

the street art and even then it was like a constant it was not it it wasn’t

a constant it was not it it wasn’t

a constant it was not it it wasn’t something I questioned it was just

something I questioned it was just

something I questioned it was just that’s the way it is

that’s the way it is

that’s the way it is however this all changed went up it

however this all changed went up it

however this all changed went up it started affecting me and started

started affecting me and started

started affecting me and started affecting my work and changed when I

affecting my work and changed when I

affecting my work and changed when I started doing public murals and public

started doing public murals and public

started doing public murals and public murals are scary for two reasons one

murals are scary for two reasons one

murals are scary for two reasons one everybody sees it in – everyone has an

everybody sees it in – everyone has an

everybody sees it in – everyone has an opinion and you can no longer to offend

opinion and you can no longer to offend

opinion and you can no longer to offend your work and so it’s really hard to

your work and so it’s really hard to

your work and so it’s really hard to initially hear when just because I did a

initially hear when just because I did a

initially hear when just because I did a street art style people would say who

street art style people would say who

street art style people would say who vandalized that wall or when are they

vandalized that wall or when are they

vandalized that wall or when are they gonna wash it off I couldn’t help but

gonna wash it off I couldn’t help but

gonna wash it off I couldn’t help but think to myself if I had done this with

think to myself if I had done this with

think to myself if I had done this with a paintbrush instead of a can of spray

a paintbrush instead of a can of spray

a paintbrush instead of a can of spray paint would I get the respect of it

paint would I get the respect of it

paint would I get the respect of it being real art and so then I really

being real art and so then I really

being real art and so then I really started to question this division and I

started to question this division and I

started to question this division and I wanted you to know if you worked in a

wanted you to know if you worked in a

wanted you to know if you worked in a lower medium did you have any chance of

lower medium did you have any chance of

lower medium did you have any chance of getting the respect of high art so I

getting the respect of high art so I

getting the respect of high art so I wanted to find artists who worked in a

wanted to find artists who worked in a

wanted to find artists who worked in a lower medium like street art or anything

lower medium like street art or anything

lower medium like street art or anything like that but still had the respect of

like that but still had the respect of

like that but still had the respect of the higher art world so the first person

the higher art world so the first person

the higher art world so the first person I found was a guy named Banksy if you’ve

I found was a guy named Banksy if you’ve

I found was a guy named Banksy if you’ve seen this kind of style this two-tone

seen this kind of style this two-tone

seen this kind of style this two-tone stencil style it was actually created by

stencil style it was actually created by

stencil style it was actually created by a guy named Black the rat out of France

a guy named Black the rat out of France

a guy named Black the rat out of France but it’s popularized by Banksy this guy

but it’s popularized by Banksy this guy

but it’s popularized by Banksy this guy and Banksy is different than most street

and Banksy is different than most street

and Banksy is different than most street artists because unlike other street

artists because unlike other street

artists because unlike other street artists who get their work washed off

artists who get their work washed off

artists who get their work washed off the wall you know some some Doug level

the wall you know some some Doug level

the wall you know some some Doug level stuff people actually spend millions of

stuff people actually spend millions of

stuff people actually spend millions of dollars to cut the wall out of the

dollars to cut the wall out of the

dollars to cut the wall out of the building to preserve his work and you

building to preserve his work and you

building to preserve his work and you can even hear people’s respect for him

can even hear people’s respect for him

can even hear people’s respect for him because celebrities will mention his

because celebrities will mention his

because celebrities will mention his work all the time and initially that

work all the time and initially that

work all the time and initially that used to bother me like how come this guy

used to bother me like how come this guy

used to bother me like how come this guy gets special tree

gets special tree

gets special tree but then I realized that there’s more

but then I realized that there’s more

but then I realized that there’s more value in seeing what enables him to get

value in seeing what enables him to get

value in seeing what enables him to get this respect and when I came to realize

this respect and when I came to realize

this respect and when I came to realize is that he’s a master communicator he’s

is that he’s a master communicator he’s

is that he’s a master communicator he’s great at a simple image as simple in a

great at a simple image as simple in a

great at a simple image as simple in a simple or like in this example where he

simple or like in this example where he

simple or like in this example where he crosses out the IMG and adds an image of

crosses out the IMG and adds an image of

crosses out the IMG and adds an image of a girl swinging and suddenly anyone who

a girl swinging and suddenly anyone who

a girl swinging and suddenly anyone who walks by understands what this mean he’s

walks by understands what this mean he’s

walks by understands what this mean he’s great at communicating and meeting to

great at communicating and meeting to

great at communicating and meeting to the public and so and that’s what I

the public and so and that’s what I

the public and so and that’s what I realized is that his art is so good

realized is that his art is so good

realized is that his art is so good because he’s so good at communicating so

because he’s so good at communicating so

because he’s so good at communicating so knowing this I moved on to the next guy

knowing this I moved on to the next guy

knowing this I moved on to the next guy this is Bill Watterson Oh Bill Watterson

this is Bill Watterson Oh Bill Watterson

this is Bill Watterson Oh Bill Watterson if you don’t know writes and illustrates

if you don’t know writes and illustrates

if you don’t know writes and illustrates the comic book Calvin and Hobbes and

the comic book Calvin and Hobbes and

the comic book Calvin and Hobbes and growing I grew up on Calvin Hobbes

growing I grew up on Calvin Hobbes

growing I grew up on Calvin Hobbes Calvin Hobbes is a story of a second

Calvin Hobbes is a story of a second

Calvin Hobbes is a story of a second grader and his imaginary stuffed tiger

grader and his imaginary stuffed tiger

grader and his imaginary stuffed tiger however Watterson looks at comics

however Watterson looks at comics

however Watterson looks at comics differently than almost every other

differently than almost every other

differently than almost every other comic book artist to most people

comic book artist to most people

comic book artist to most people comics are almost formulaic you have

comics are almost formulaic you have

comics are almost formulaic you have three boxes that are set up and then a

three boxes that are set up and then a

three boxes that are set up and then a fourth that’s a punch line

fourth that’s a punch line

fourth that’s a punch line however Watterson doesn’t let this

however Watterson doesn’t let this

however Watterson doesn’t let this formula define what he can address in

formula define what he can address in

formula define what he can address in his comic strips

his comic strips

his comic strips Watterson looks at it differently

Watterson looks at it differently

Watterson looks at it differently Watterson and his comic strips will

Watterson and his comic strips will

Watterson and his comic strips will address complex issues like religion and

address complex issues like religion and

address complex issues like religion and education and Watterson even has a quote

education and Watterson even has a quote

education and Watterson even has a quote that says there’s no such thing as high

that says there’s no such thing as high

that says there’s no such thing as high and low art simply art that conveys a

and low art simply art that conveys a

and low art simply art that conveys a meaning that artists is not so I

meaning that artists is not so I

meaning that artists is not so I realized that between the two what makes

realized that between the two what makes

realized that between the two what makes art good is their ability to communicate

art good is their ability to communicate

art good is their ability to communicate a meaning and that this line between

a meaning and that this line between

a meaning and that this line between high and low art really doesn’t mean

high and low art really doesn’t mean

high and low art really doesn’t mean anything but even then I had to take it

anything but even then I had to take it

anything but even then I had to take it one step further

one step further

one step further so in this text the next step is I will

so in this text the next step is I will

so in this text the next step is I will I’m starting to question we’re starting

I’m starting to question we’re starting

I’m starting to question we’re starting to question has the higher art world

to question has the higher art world

to question has the higher art world gone too far has the business our world

gone too far has the business our world

gone too far has the business our world gone too far and trying to justify this

gone too far and trying to justify this

gone too far and trying to justify this answer to how come I should spend a

answer to how come I should spend a

answer to how come I should spend a million dollars on this work of art in

million dollars on this work of art in

million dollars on this work of art in trying to answer this question

trying to answer this question

trying to answer this question they’ve inflated the

they’ve inflated the

they’ve inflated the artists they’ve said you should pay this

artists they’ve said you should pay this

artists they’ve said you should pay this much money for this piece of work

much money for this piece of work

much money for this piece of work because this artist is a genius they’re

because this artist is a genius they’re

because this artist is a genius they’re not some normal person and that anyone

not some normal person and that anyone

not some normal person and that anyone who is unable to understand

who is unable to understand

who is unable to understand their work also has to be a genius it

their work also has to be a genius it

their work also has to be a genius it creates this hierarchy and this was seen

creates this hierarchy and this was seen

creates this hierarchy and this was seen in the book that I read Bluebeard by

in the book that I read Bluebeard by

in the book that I read Bluebeard by Kurt Vonnegut which is a mock

Kurt Vonnegut which is a mock

Kurt Vonnegut which is a mock autobiography of a retired artist as he

autobiography of a retired artist as he

autobiography of a retired artist as he goes and reflects through the obstacles

goes and reflects through the obstacles

goes and reflects through the obstacles that the art world has put in his place

that the art world has put in his place

that the art world has put in his place and he has a quote in the end that says

and he has a quote in the end that says

and he has a quote in the end that says in a world of Champions the mediocre

in a world of Champions the mediocre

in a world of Champions the mediocre often discourage to try and that’s what

often discourage to try and that’s what

often discourage to try and that’s what this hierarchy does this hierarchy of

this hierarchy does this hierarchy of

this hierarchy does this hierarchy of elitism causes the average Joe the

elitism causes the average Joe the

elitism causes the average Joe the regular person to not even try to engage

regular person to not even try to engage

regular person to not even try to engage in art if they because they feel

in art if they because they feel

in art if they because they feel intimidated like I did when I went to

intimidated like I did when I went to

intimidated like I did when I went to the gallery and what this allows them to

the gallery and what this allows them to

the gallery and what this allows them to do is it allows them to tell us what is

do is it allows them to tell us what is

do is it allows them to tell us what is and what isn’t art and in order to fight

and what isn’t art and in order to fight

and what isn’t art and in order to fight this what we need to do is change our

this what we need to do is change our

this what we need to do is change our thinking so imagine a bowl beautiful

thinking so imagine a bowl beautiful

thinking so imagine a bowl beautiful ceramic bowl right and then drop it on

ceramic bowl right and then drop it on

ceramic bowl right and then drop it on the ground and it shatters everywhere

the ground and it shatters everywhere

the ground and it shatters everywhere it’s it’s worthless right it’s trash

it’s it’s worthless right it’s trash

it’s it’s worthless right it’s trash it’s lower than low art however what the

it’s lower than low art however what the

it’s lower than low art however what the Japanese do is something different

Japanese do is something different

Japanese do is something different they’ll take a broken ceramic bowl or

they’ll take a broken ceramic bowl or

they’ll take a broken ceramic bowl or ceramic cup and they’ll mend it back

ceramic cup and they’ll mend it back

ceramic cup and they’ll mend it back together with gold putty because their

together with gold putty because their

together with gold putty because their idea is it’s the flaws it’s the cracks

idea is it’s the flaws it’s the cracks

idea is it’s the flaws it’s the cracks that make something beautiful and this

that make something beautiful and this

that make something beautiful and this is how we need to go about thinking

is how we need to go about thinking

is how we need to go about thinking about art art doesn’t need to be perfect

about art art doesn’t need to be perfect

about art art doesn’t need to be perfect art doesn’t need to be something that

art doesn’t need to be something that

art doesn’t need to be something that only geniuses can do art can be

only geniuses can do art can be

only geniuses can do art can be something that anyone does because it’s

something that anyone does because it’s

something that anyone does because it’s the imperfections it’s the the cracks

the imperfections it’s the the cracks

the imperfections it’s the the cracks that make art express a meaning it gives

that make art express a meaning it gives

that make art express a meaning it gives it character and this is so important

it character and this is so important

it character and this is so important because art is important because art is

because art is important because art is

because art is important because art is the gold putty that mends the broken

the gold putty that mends the broken

the gold putty that mends the broken world back together thank you

world back together thank you

world back together thank you [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *