Press "Enter" to skip to content

L’école sert-elle encore à quelque chose? | Dimitri Rechov | TEDxSciencesPoCampusDijon


[Applause]

Hello everyone

I will tell you the story of Enzo

enzo

like a lot of kids his age is going

enter kindergarten in september

next

what he does not know yet is who is going

to confront a huge male and

invisible this evil is conformism the

conformist begin to manifest themselves

from kindergarten we start having

evaluations even though it’s still

notes we start taking a

language not just any language a

particular language and so

general his debut of pressure

social group pressures at school

enzo learn to read with pump and

reflect

but he will also understand that for

to have a sesame of an evaluation

positive

we will have to comply with the system

the college of which kenzo in shenzhen

year is confirmed will take off the water

will start to learn the

mechanisms of the dissertations which is to

share is equal for all and college

by the way under the guise of equality is going

select high school now it’s

the advent is the culmination of

this logic the temple of conformism

with its non-nonconformist rhythm of the

ferry the ferry that for those without a doubt

that they spent and more than one ordeal

where the goal is to relocate the most

possible knowledge at a given moment

is not so much the reflection of a true

doping learning does what we

sees is that at each at each

stage we find conformism and

all this system works a little on

injunction

walk or die either

enzo will comply in this case there

has good results

he has the directions who wants he

reaches into good channels and I

do not throw very landmarks because

me even if I’m here by the banks

today is that I knew in

benefit from this conformism

but if the water on the other hand has trouble

if there are gaps if he does not understand

what is expected of him here at Nimes in

the plate and his knowledge about the

paper

tired the difficulties begin because

that we are going to be redoubled enzo

may be hugging and doing a

die against his will and maybe

that enzo will even be in check

school and get off and when we see

what is being said about

school we see that cases like enzo

d enzo in difficulty there are many

it is common knowledge that

the French school is selective

unequal and unable to respond

at school failure

then these date premiums

obviously not yesterday and some are going

seek recourse to the return bardon

the school of the 50s of the 60s

even for the more daring to

the school of the third republic and

they will argue that at the time the

master was all powerful

the obedient student and that failure

did not exist you can imagine it’s

false

this school is a myth this school

is a fantasy she probably has

never existed and what is certain is

that there will never be anything

must today is a break

radical with conformism a

true educational revolution

you will tell me yes but a wide

part of the difficulties are not

explained by conformism and you

are right there is of course weakness

means

there is of course the problem of

inequalities but the question of

conformism and too often obscured this

moment and when we hear the opinion

public who often blame the

youth passivity they miss

initiative and that on the other side we

sees these young people who answer in a

some way dreaming of leaving

the France and I do not know if you have

heard but a few months ago

there was the story of this

student who wrote to françois

Holland

the reasons for his expatriation when one

see that we understand

me personally anyway I

understand those people my age who

have a hard time finding themselves in this

system of an educational system that is

not tender that was very demanding

can be too demanding that sets the

very high bar in terms of

knowledge in terms of skills

and which ultimately leaves little room for

creativity where the personality

I’m not trying to blacken

table

I do not seek a brain chart

since the post-war period with everything

we know about democratization the

massification according to the points of view and

especially since these last thirty

years of reforms were made

to put the student a little more to

center of the system be it by the

setting up to accompany

personalized support to

middle school and high school by the test of

personal work supervised at

baccalaureate that forces students to

think in groups or even

by the presence at the baccalaureate

artistic proof is optional

aims a little bit at putting evaluation

extracurricular also in the

bachelor’s degree and even the last

college reform

whatever we think about it also goes in

that sense but these reforms are without

doubt insufficient in view of the stakes

which must be answered before

school must be public school

after the war was to form

citizens and seasoned workers

who would be obedient when he

must and discreet remains time the

conformism was not a problem

because the school had to be

homogenizing you are today we have it

seen with the crisis of the school system

with the new issues they are

ecological social policies

societal

the stakes are others who said stake

other said new system from where

the interest of a radical reform but

attention this radical reform does not

does not mean breaking and total abandonment of the

current system the French system

even if we can criticize it remains to

in many ways better than

other alternatives is an example in

is the dissertation

because on one side the dissertation

it is an eminently republican tool

a tool that forces students to

take a stand to reflect on a

subject and to confront the different

positions on it but it’s also a

tool that can be stigmatizing

because the difficulty of life

difficulty of the dissertation is not

of the same for all some are going

assimilated the mechanism very quickly

others have a lot more trouble and he

is a huge problem of methodology

of a French system because we share

the principle that everyone is equal

face this difficulty but this is

not the case everyone does not have

the codes of the dissertation and if we do not

does not have the codes one can not

play the game we can not adopt

critical position or to have

reflection that’s why and the

dissertation by the way like any

which exercise can not be summed up in

only store knowledge

maybe it goes through a little bit

less learning but a

better learning and

the purpose of all this is to organize the

reflection initiated the reflection of a

try to organize the debate where the

students might even should

give their opinion from their

knowledge but also and especially

from their own opinion

school can not be reduced to the

only evaluation and evaluation

besides which I do not like

of interest must also be seen must

to be reviewed to be more positive

to really rely on knowledge

acquired and not system compliance

the note should not be an end

she must remain a medium and the average

this famous 10 out of 20 does not have to be a

cleaver you probably know the

constant macabre phenomenon which is

means a constant percentage of

bad grades no matter the duty

no matter which teacher no matter to

class this phenomenon actually describes the

disconnect between notes and know and the

problem with the addiction of

connections between notes and know it’s

that evaluation

I’m doing more on some

objective thing but is done on the

compliance with the system and therefore fight

against conformism it’s also

accept and anticipate difficulties

at school is questioning

the idea al damiri single brother and a

archetype of good students to whom he

would absolutely comply is

accept that merit and plural and

that each one a potential and that’s saying

that’s not calling into question the

quality of a system where the quality

given diplomas

it’s only accepting the fact that we

can not train a student

excellent at the price of abandoning nine

other weaker students say this

not everyone is accepting

potential and that the school does not have to

to format this potential

so some people also say very

present in the public debate that

the school is not good enough for the

professional life to the requirements

of business knowledge acquired are

too abstract but I think it’s

rather the contrary

school is no longer a place of

learning training but become

rather an institution where we have to

apply knowledge and that’s it’s a

problem and the school can not we

will boil down to an apprenticeship of

interested conformism he sweeps

any notion of learning

interested it boils down to actually a

simple mechanism ingested and

regurgitate knowledge and the school and

I think can go further from there a

example in n maybe some of between

they know the currency the currency is

a show ridden by the theater

dijon bourgogne a few months ago and who

was played in high schools and as

his name indicated the purpose was to

to reflect on the translated meaning

French what involved

today and especially to debate

the students on after the play and

it works and it worked because

just for once we asked the

students what they thought not

only to apply and accept

mechanically the motto freedom

equality fraternity but also to

think about the meaning and that I think

really that it is possible to

the scale of all schools and

the whole of France

it is possible and even necessary for

that students may have a setback

on what they learn can have

a rain a critical position so that

themselves can exceed their

own prejudices and also put

end to self exclusion and self

disqualification that drives some to

failure

we must break these mentalities

we must reject conformism for

create a new school a school

where the social mix would be assured

a school where schools

would be co-managed by the students and

the staff

a school where classes would be

maybe smaller but to students

to better accompany and a school where

the note would not be determinative of

all the rejection of conformism is

that a first step in this long

way to school in the 21st century

a school that would not wait

enslave south but free will

a school that would train citizens

engaged and politicized and not

passive citizens we deserve better

that a eugenic school a school that

could have very well imagined him

succeeds at sea of ​​the worlds the

conformism is not the exclusive preserve of

totalitarianism

it exists in our democracies and

was a great danger it is for

that we have to chase the

conformism our school is the 21st

century will be the century of school

contrarian or will not be thank you

[Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *