Press "Enter" to skip to content

How stories overcome differences | Raphael Rodan & Sahand Sahebdivani | TEDxDenHelder


for the last couple of years me and my

for the last couple of years me and my best friend we’ve been traveling to many

best friend we’ve been traveling to many

best friend we’ve been traveling to many stages all over the world and we’ve been

stages all over the world and we’ve been

stages all over the world and we’ve been sharing our stories we’ve performed in

sharing our stories we’ve performed in

sharing our stories we’ve performed in museums and theatres often performing

museums and theatres often performing

museums and theatres often performing for adults but not always yeah sometimes

for adults but not always yeah sometimes

for adults but not always yeah sometimes we also perform to teenagers and we

we also perform to teenagers and we

we also perform to teenagers and we always like to start in in in a playful

always like to start in in in a playful

always like to start in in in a playful manner we tell them that one of us is

manner we tell them that one of us is

manner we tell them that one of us is Israeli and the other was other one is

Israeli and the other was other one is

Israeli and the other was other one is Iranian and we ask them who is who

Iranian and we ask them who is who

Iranian and we ask them who is who but then we always add one thing we go

but then we always add one thing we go

but then we always add one thing we go and we tell them you better guess it

and we tell them you better guess it

and we tell them you better guess it right because if not we’re gonna blow

right because if not we’re gonna blow

right because if not we’re gonna blow the place up it’s true even did it today

the place up it’s true even did it today

the place up it’s true even did it today we went to some of the people that we

we went to some of the people that we

we went to some of the people that we met outside and we asked them the same

met outside and we asked them the same

met outside and we asked them the same question and about half the people we

question and about half the people we

question and about half the people we asked got it completely wrong which

asked got it completely wrong which

asked got it completely wrong which tells us quite a few things it tells us

tells us quite a few things it tells us

tells us quite a few things it tells us first of all that even if there is all

first of all that even if there is all

first of all that even if there is all these stories in the media that we

these stories in the media that we

these stories in the media that we should be so different him the Israeli

should be so different him the Israeli

should be so different him the Israeli me the Iranian if people can’t even tell

me the Iranian if people can’t even tell

me the Iranian if people can’t even tell the difference is there even really a

the difference is there even really a

the difference is there even really a difference and it’s true it’s true there

difference and it’s true it’s true there

difference and it’s true it’s true there are a lot of similarities we are very

are a lot of similarities we are very

are a lot of similarities we are very good friends we discovered over our

good friends we discovered over our

good friends we discovered over our friendship that we have a lot of things

friendship that we have a lot of things

friendship that we have a lot of things of things in common but we also have

of things in common but we also have

of things in common but we also have some differences now I don’t know if you

some differences now I don’t know if you

some differences now I don’t know if you guys know anything about Iranian culture

guys know anything about Iranian culture

guys know anything about Iranian culture but I’ll tell you one thing these guys

but I’ll tell you one thing these guys

but I’ll tell you one thing these guys they are incredibly incredibly polite

they are incredibly incredibly polite

they are incredibly incredibly polite yeah that’s true yeah someone agrees in

yeah that’s true yeah someone agrees in

yeah that’s true yeah someone agrees in the audience I’ll tell you I know him

the audience I’ll tell you I know him

the audience I’ll tell you I know him for four years I still don’t know what

for four years I still don’t know what

for four years I still don’t know what he thinks of me he loves me he hates me

he thinks of me he loves me he hates me

he thinks of me he loves me he hates me yes no it’s all hiding underneath this

yes no it’s all hiding underneath this

yes no it’s all hiding underneath this kind of mask of polite nice smile you

kind of mask of polite nice smile you

kind of mask of polite nice smile you say it like it’s a bad thing

say it like it’s a bad thing

say it like it’s a bad thing come on no politeness is important for

come on no politeness is important for

come on no politeness is important for us if Iranians go into a theatre even if

us if Iranians go into a theatre even if

us if Iranians go into a theatre even if there is people you don’t know the

there is people you don’t know the

there is people you don’t know the people in the front they’re ashamed that

people in the front they’re ashamed that

people in the front they’re ashamed that their back is facing someone so they

their back is facing someone so they

their back is facing someone so they will apologize and then the person in

will apologize and then the person in

will apologize and then the person in the back will say oh don’t worry a

the back will say oh don’t worry a

the back will say oh don’t worry a flower doesn’t have a front or a back

flower doesn’t have a front or a back

flower doesn’t have a front or a back how’s that for politeness er good right

how’s that for politeness er good right

how’s that for politeness er good right huh okay let me let me add one thing not

huh okay let me let me add one thing not

huh okay let me let me add one thing not just a polite smile poetic beautiful

just a polite smile poetic beautiful

just a polite smile poetic beautiful as well yes yes as opposed to the

as well yes yes as opposed to the

as well yes yes as opposed to the Israeli who very much like to open every

Israeli who very much like to open every

Israeli who very much like to open every subject by kicking open the door

subject by kicking open the door

subject by kicking open the door bursting and haha you know no not for us

bursting and haha you know no not for us

bursting and haha you know no not for us we like to create some kind of stage for

we like to create some kind of stage for

we like to create some kind of stage for communication friendliness kindness

communication friendliness kindness

communication friendliness kindness friendliness yes you know what my

friendliness yes you know what my

friendliness yes you know what my grandmother would say about this kind of

grandmother would say about this kind of

grandmother would say about this kind of friendliness I’ll tell you a friend with

friendliness I’ll tell you a friend with

friendliness I’ll tell you a friend with everyone is a friend with no one did you

everyone is a friend with no one did you

everyone is a friend with no one did you hear that they agree with me

hear that they agree with me

hear that they agree with me really yeah well you know what my

really yeah well you know what my

really yeah well you know what my grandmother would say to them friendship

grandmother would say to them friendship

grandmother would say to them friendship can have all directions its animosity

can have all directions its animosity

can have all directions its animosity that has a very clear direction well you

that has a very clear direction well you

that has a very clear direction well you know what my grandmother would say about

know what my grandmother would say about

know what my grandmother would say about this true friends they stab you in the

this true friends they stab you in the

this true friends they stab you in the front not in the back huh but my friends

front not in the back huh but my friends

front not in the back huh but my friends a flower doesn’t have a front or a back

a flower doesn’t have a front or a back

a flower doesn’t have a front or a back I let you win I let him win okay okay so

I let you win I let him win okay okay so

I let you win I let him win okay okay so similarities and differences but if our

similarities and differences but if our

similarities and differences but if our work would stop there with the stories

work would stop there with the stories

work would stop there with the stories that we tell only on that surface level

that we tell only on that surface level

that we tell only on that surface level level of identity it would be quite

level of identity it would be quite

level of identity it would be quite superficial now we like to go deeper

superficial now we like to go deeper

superficial now we like to go deeper with it we actually realized there is

with it we actually realized there is

with it we actually realized there is there’s this question underneath that

there’s this question underneath that

there’s this question underneath that that we want to ask ourselves and we

that we want to ask ourselves and we

that we want to ask ourselves and we asked ourselves a very fundamental

asked ourselves a very fundamental

asked ourselves a very fundamental question we asked herself when was the

question we asked herself when was the

question we asked herself when was the first moment in our life that we became

first moment in our life that we became

first moment in our life that we became aware of the fact that we belong to any

aware of the fact that we belong to any

aware of the fact that we belong to any group because let’s be honest what does

group because let’s be honest what does

group because let’s be honest what does a baby know about being Israeli or

a baby know about being Israeli or

a baby know about being Israeli or Iranian right it starts at a certain

Iranian right it starts at a certain

Iranian right it starts at a certain moment these layers of our identity that

moment these layers of our identity that

moment these layers of our identity that we put on ourselves and gradually to the

we put on ourselves and gradually to the

we put on ourselves and gradually to the point that we say we are this and we are

point that we say we are this and we are

point that we say we are this and we are that and these layers how are they

that and these layers how are they

that and these layers how are they created well many times by stories

created well many times by stories

created well many times by stories stories of our ancestors of our heroes

stories of our ancestors of our heroes

stories of our ancestors of our heroes of the failures of the people we loved

of the failures of the people we loved

of the failures of the people we loved and like this gradually a certain skin

and like this gradually a certain skin

and like this gradually a certain skin is placed on us and underneath it for us

is placed on us and underneath it for us

is placed on us and underneath it for us is there is a there is a question that

is there is a there is a question that

is there is a there is a question that it

it

it who are we so this question who are we

who are we so this question who are we

who are we so this question who are we but also this question of when was the

but also this question of when was the

but also this question of when was the moment that you were claimed by your

moment that you were claimed by your

moment that you were claimed by your group that you realized you were part of

group that you realized you were part of

group that you realized you were part of one group and you were not part of

one group and you were not part of

one group and you were not part of another group this we took to our

another group this we took to our

another group this we took to our mothers he to his mother and me to my

mothers he to his mother and me to my

mothers he to his mother and me to my mother yeah me to my mother with a

mother yeah me to my mother with a

mother yeah me to my mother with a Jewish woman that grew up in Iran

Jewish woman that grew up in Iran

Jewish woman that grew up in Iran actually and only later in her life she

actually and only later in her life she

actually and only later in her life she came to Israel yeah and my mother who is

came to Israel yeah and my mother who is

came to Israel yeah and my mother who is also from Iran but came from a Muslim

also from Iran but came from a Muslim

also from Iran but came from a Muslim family now this is a story that my

family now this is a story that my

family now this is a story that my mother told me she said that she was six

mother told me she said that she was six

mother told me she said that she was six years old a six year old girl who simply

years old a six year old girl who simply

years old a six year old girl who simply loved to sing more than anything in life

loved to sing more than anything in life

loved to sing more than anything in life and at that age being with shy she would

and at that age being with shy she would

and at that age being with shy she would always wait for her mother to go to the

always wait for her mother to go to the

always wait for her mother to go to the market then she would have the house for

market then she would have the house for

market then she would have the house for herself and she would practice and

herself and she would practice and

herself and she would practice and practice the songs and in those days you

practice the songs and in those days you

practice the songs and in those days you know pop songs didn’t have very cheaply

know pop songs didn’t have very cheaply

know pop songs didn’t have very cheaply right no they were written by real poets

right no they were written by real poets

right no they were written by real poets and these words like rubies diamonds

and these words like rubies diamonds

and these words like rubies diamonds emeralds they would come out of her

emeralds they would come out of her

emeralds they would come out of her mouth my mother told me that when she

mouth my mother told me that when she

mouth my mother told me that when she was six years old back in Iran she was

was six years old back in Iran she was

was six years old back in Iran she was waiting for the moment that her mother

waiting for the moment that her mother

waiting for the moment that her mother will take her to the marketplace you

will take her to the marketplace you

will take her to the marketplace you know what they called her cholera SIA it

know what they called her cholera SIA it

know what they called her cholera SIA it means a Black Raven why because she

means a Black Raven why because she

means a Black Raven why because she didn’t have the white skin of her sister

didn’t have the white skin of her sister

didn’t have the white skin of her sister and the green eyes she was dark but my

and the green eyes she was dark but my

and the green eyes she was dark but my mother has one really strong

mother has one really strong

mother has one really strong characteristic she is very very stubborn

characteristic she is very very stubborn

characteristic she is very very stubborn so she kept nagging my grandmother take

so she kept nagging my grandmother take

so she kept nagging my grandmother take me to the marketplace take me to the

me to the marketplace take me to the

me to the marketplace take me to the marketplace take me to the marketplace

marketplace take me to the marketplace

marketplace take me to the marketplace until my grandmother said okay okay when

until my grandmother said okay okay when

until my grandmother said okay okay when you’ll be seven I’ll take you okay

you’ll be seven I’ll take you okay

you’ll be seven I’ll take you okay what do you think happened the day she

what do you think happened the day she

what do you think happened the day she turned seven it was dark outside when my

turned seven it was dark outside when my

turned seven it was dark outside when my mother was already up with my grandma

mother was already up with my grandma

mother was already up with my grandma most beautiful hijab decorated with red

most beautiful hijab decorated with red

most beautiful hijab decorated with red flowers standing next to my

flowers standing next to my

flowers standing next to my grandmother’s bed shaking hair telling

grandmother’s bed shaking hair telling

grandmother’s bed shaking hair telling her I’m seven are you going to take me

her I’m seven are you going to take me

her I’m seven are you going to take me to the marketplace well a promise is a

to the marketplace well a promise is a

to the marketplace well a promise is a promise and my mother told me how she

promise and my mother told me how she

promise and my mother told me how she was amazed by this marketplace this is

was amazed by this marketplace this is

was amazed by this marketplace this is not Albert Heijn you know

not Albert Heijn you know

not Albert Heijn you know the smells of the spices the colors of

the smells of the spices the colors of

the smells of the spices the colors of the fruits seeing the man picking up the

the fruits seeing the man picking up the

the fruits seeing the man picking up the watermelon tapping them to see if they

watermelon tapping them to see if they

watermelon tapping them to see if they were ripe and my mother she was so

were ripe and my mother she was so

were ripe and my mother she was so excited she ran forward and she found

excited she ran forward and she found

excited she ran forward and she found herself in front of a vegetable stall

herself in front of a vegetable stall

herself in front of a vegetable stall and there in front of her eyes she saw

and there in front of her eyes she saw

and there in front of her eyes she saw this big fat black aubergine and she

this big fat black aubergine and she

this big fat black aubergine and she reached out to touch it and she will

reached out to touch it and she will

reached out to touch it and she will never forget what her mother told her

never forget what her mother told her

never forget what her mother told her then my mother will never forget what

then my mother will never forget what

then my mother will never forget what her mother told her when she came back

her mother told her when she came back

her mother told her when she came back from the market you remember the six

from the market you remember the six

from the market you remember the six year old girl who loved to sing she’s

year old girl who loved to sing she’s

year old girl who loved to sing she’s there she’s practicing and suddenly the

there she’s practicing and suddenly the

there she’s practicing and suddenly the door of the house opens she hears the

door of the house opens she hears the

door of the house opens she hears the footsteps of her mother in the hallway

footsteps of her mother in the hallway

footsteps of her mother in the hallway she sees a mother stand in front of her

she sees a mother stand in front of her

she sees a mother stand in front of her pointing a finger at her saying don’t

pointing a finger at her saying don’t

pointing a finger at her saying don’t sing don’t touch that’s what my

sing don’t touch that’s what my

sing don’t touch that’s what my grandmother said to my mother and then

grandmother said to my mother and then

grandmother said to my mother and then my grandmother she pointed out the

my grandmother she pointed out the

my grandmother she pointed out the vegetables without touching them and the

vegetables without touching them and the

vegetables without touching them and the seller he placed them in a box and he

seller he placed them in a box and he

seller he placed them in a box and he handed the box to my grandmother why

handed the box to my grandmother why

handed the box to my grandmother why can’t I sing simple question from a

can’t I sing simple question from a

can’t I sing simple question from a six-year-old girl to her mother why

six-year-old girl to her mother why

six-year-old girl to her mother why can’t I sing and her mother explained

can’t I sing and her mother explained

can’t I sing and her mother explained with a lot of patience you see my girl

with a lot of patience you see my girl

with a lot of patience you see my girl if you sing and a man you’re not related

if you sing and a man you’re not related

if you sing and a man you’re not related to hears your voice he will have bad

to hears your voice he will have bad

to hears your voice he will have bad thoughts and then he will go to hell and

thoughts and then he will go to hell and

thoughts and then he will go to hell and then because you gave him those thoughts

then because you gave him those thoughts

then because you gave him those thoughts you will go to hell I have friends in

you will go to hell I have friends in

you will go to hell I have friends in school they sing yeah very unfortunate

school they sing yeah very unfortunate

school they sing yeah very unfortunate for your friends but we don’t sing we

for your friends but we don’t sing we

for your friends but we don’t sing we are proper Muslims why couldn’t touch

are proper Muslims why couldn’t touch

are proper Muslims why couldn’t touch touch the vegetables that’s what my

touch the vegetables that’s what my

touch the vegetables that’s what my mother asked well you couldn’t have

mother asked well you couldn’t have

mother asked well you couldn’t have touched the vegetables because if you

touched the vegetables because if you

touched the vegetables because if you would have nobody else would why all the

would have nobody else would why all the

would have nobody else would why all the other people were doing it yes but we

other people were doing it yes but we

other people were doing it yes but we are not like all the other people you

are not like all the other people you

are not like all the other people you see my child because we are Jewish

well it is a narrative that was told a

well it is a narrative that was told a long time ago and it’s a narrative that

long time ago and it’s a narrative that

long time ago and it’s a narrative that [Music]

[Music]

[Music] took these two girls who could have been

took these two girls who could have been

took these two girls who could have been friends and separated them but you see

friends and separated them but you see

friends and separated them but you see our generation us we work with these

our generation us we work with these

our generation us we work with these narratives they’re our bread and butter

narratives they’re our bread and butter

narratives they’re our bread and butter we look for them we ask them to be told

we look for them we ask them to be told

we look for them we ask them to be told we dive into them we ask other people to

we dive into them we ask other people to

we dive into them we ask other people to tell their stories so that we understand

tell their stories so that we understand

tell their stories so that we understand who we are and who they are and what are

who we are and who they are and what are

who we are and who they are and what are the layers that are put upon us and a

the layers that are put upon us and a

the layers that are put upon us and a lot of this we do also in our school the

lot of this we do also in our school the

lot of this we do also in our school the master of storytelling school so in a

master of storytelling school so in a

master of storytelling school so in a way the narrative brings us together but

way the narrative brings us together but

way the narrative brings us together but not just us also our mothers and this is

not just us also our mothers and this is

not just us also our mothers and this is funny because I moved to Amsterdam and

funny because I moved to Amsterdam and

funny because I moved to Amsterdam and my mother came to visit me a year ago

my mother came to visit me a year ago

my mother came to visit me a year ago and when she came I told her hey I want

and when she came I told her hey I want

and when she came I told her hey I want you to meet my best friend so we went to

you to meet my best friend so we went to

you to meet my best friend so we went to visit this guy and he’s a little Iranian

visit this guy and he’s a little Iranian

visit this guy and he’s a little Iranian flat in the west of Amsterdam and from

flat in the west of Amsterdam and from

flat in the west of Amsterdam and from the first moment my mother entered that

the first moment my mother entered that

the first moment my mother entered that house I saw a child the carpets

house I saw a child the carpets

house I saw a child the carpets you know looking at the walls as if

you know looking at the walls as if

you know looking at the walls as if she’s remembering a world she had

she’s remembering a world she had

she’s remembering a world she had forgotten and I she was sitting on there

forgotten and I she was sitting on there

forgotten and I she was sitting on there on the couch and then his mother came

on the couch and then his mother came

on the couch and then his mother came and sat in front of her and at that

and sat in front of her and at that

and sat in front of her and at that moment yes she took her hand and at that

moment yes she took her hand and at that

moment yes she took her hand and at that moment my mother started speaking in

moment my mother started speaking in

moment my mother started speaking in Farsi I didn’t understand the world but

Farsi I didn’t understand the world but

Farsi I didn’t understand the world but it looked wonderful for hours you know

it looked wonderful for hours you know

it looked wonderful for hours you know these two women went once stroking the

these two women went once stroking the

these two women went once stroking the hand of the other by the way telling my

hand of the other by the way telling my

hand of the other by the way telling my father bring some ice cream yalla Ali

father bring some ice cream yalla Ali

father bring some ice cream yalla Ali come on come on I want to feed my best

come on come on I want to feed my best

come on come on I want to feed my best friend and they were together like this

friend and they were together like this

friend and they were together like this you know after all these years now I

you know after all these years now I

you know after all these years now I don’t know maybe some of you would think

don’t know maybe some of you would think

don’t know maybe some of you would think are these guys their storytellers

are these guys their storytellers

are these guys their storytellers they’re exaggerating it was a sad story

they’re exaggerating it was a sad story

they’re exaggerating it was a sad story they wanted to end it in a positive note

they wanted to end it in a positive note

they wanted to end it in a positive note it’s not true well especially for you we

it’s not true well especially for you we

it’s not true well especially for you we brought a proof

brought a proof

brought a proof come on Irfan stand over here yes here

come on Irfan stand over here yes here

come on Irfan stand over here yes here you see them the one time that they met

you see them the one time that they met

you see them the one time that they met in our house my mother and his mother

in our house my mother and his mother

in our house my mother and his mother ladies and gentlemen the power of story

ladies and gentlemen the power of story

ladies and gentlemen the power of story [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *