Press "Enter" to skip to content

Dios no es argentino | Luciana Sabina | TEDxParqueSanMartín


[Music]

the laws throughout our life

we have heard that phrase many times

so famous of God is Argentinian but

attends in Buenos Aires and generally

it’s not very logical, not because behind

of that phrase is what we think about

what we are

on the one hand a unique elected people

we are special are very different

Argentines to the point that God

choose to be Argentine and for another

part of our way of organizing

centralist

everything goes through Buenos Aires everything is

organized from Buenos Aires and we

we live, we are aware of what is happening

to the point that any artist who

He triumphs in Buenos Aires when he returns to

his hometown begins to fill the

theaters that before I know nothing

this usually does not close the point of

view of centralism is something very

evident above all those who live in

we see the provinces and we have

suffered sometimes but what are we so

perfect that we are that people

chosen is a little harder to

check ourselves along

our lives emotion

we have observed different crises

economic social policies always

and if we went a little more to Argentina

it starts being one of the ten countries

most important in the world in the century

20 and ends up being a country with

high rates of their developments to this

talk what you are looking for is that we see a

little like that with what we are a country

that is not so perfect and a people that

it’s not as perfect as we want it

It took me a lot to start looking at another

way and I want to show you what the

travel he made through

experiences through different

texts the first time I started to

look at us differently or differently from a

text that came to my hands of ortega and

gasset protect and do for me is

that moment in a house

I really did not have

it degenerates but it was a philosopher

Spanish that we loved the team

came the Argentine was fascinated him

loved how we were he loved the

country lived on three occasions and the

last one stayed to live a while and

as they did not want more critical so that

let’s improve he said the Argentines

we were like the pampas because as the

panga because observing the landscape in a

trip he made by train from good

Aires to Mendoza realized that

pampas we could not see the end that is to the

observe the era a promise is a

promise where massa had something good

there was something fertile and the Argentines

we should always in that future in that

promise that we never arrived

we are always waiting for the country

improve or not

basically ortega do he told us that and

He asked us to look a little on the

present because we lived in the future

that never came and we did not lend

nothing attention then god said a

phrase that you must have also heard

much that is Argentines to things

yes yes today ortega and gasset even

I would have a twitter will surely go today

has posted and had people who did

they supported as victory or field

yes but most rejected it because

He put the mirror in front and we did not like it

what we saw ortega is based on the year

42 from Buenos Aires and never returns

more to Argentina but a few years

before he visits us in 1925

nothing more and nothing less than albert

einstein and stein who was a person who

was responsible for giving answers is going with

a great unknown of our country does not

can understand how the argentina

it worked

basically is the question asked

and why can not he understand how

nothing works because the guy says in

this country nobody respects the rules

nobody respects the laws the rules

anyone violate it is a mess

he said he could not understand how we were

a power still at that time was

so disastrous everything

the answer to this some people look for it in

a political party or look for it in a

political in particular but the reality

is that those parties are politicians

or whatever it is they are a manifestation of

ourselves

I only realized through another

man who changes after a text in

reality that was called rosemary joseph

luis romero

the historian who wrote a lot about

the average age because he does not want to have

problems with Argentines ever

Argentine but at one time he wrote

a very good book about us and

explains why Argentines do not

we could comply with the rules is

our base when the

Spanish to America

we all know what happened with the

aborigines but little we know that there was

laws to protect us that came to

america but goals were not met

on the part of King Charles fifth yes that

had the Spaniards to take care of them

feed them to aboriginal groups

who were in charge of these laws did not

they served because they go against their

interests

then they took out a legal contraption was

it is obeyed but it is not fulfilled is to say this

it’s fine I only understand but it’s

impracticable in america in spain

you know what our reality is

then they discarded it and the rest of the

history we already know all

another one of the issues that only in

where this was seen was also the

contraband at that time

we could only buy any

thing Spain and only two came

ships per year america bringing what

we had asked then if I

I wanted a piano I did not have to order

and had to wait approximately

five years and if the ship sank

osorno memorian media fell into the hands of

pirates had the piano but also

she did not enter by buenos aires

for Peru because Buenos Aires was a

port that could not trade what was

what happened to start smuggling

the authorities knew that there was

contraband because a ship was evident

English in the middle of the harbor and they did not

nothing is more they violated the law and were to

Please then explains that the rosemary

Argentines grew up naturalizing the

violation of the law of the rules no

respect them from the beginning even

when we were not Argentineans many

years later Darwin visited us in 1833

and note that not only that had

happened was the name that is fixed

obviously in the evolution of those of

men do not realize that in addition

of not complying with the law

the Argentines what we did was

defend the offender they helped him

to escape from there to help

escape

if you that’s what I think

would postpone today darwin was terrified him

it seemed terrible and there we see that this

which is one of the great

contradictions that we have because in

reality to what today with this talk is

see our contradictions until the

contradiction that we want God

and we are not

obviously one of the great

contradictions is that we

we expect politicians to act

well that they respect us we march

so that our rights are fulfilled

but all the time we are violating

rules and all the time we are violating

laws even when I did not know how to handle

he easily realizes because he does not

you just have to pay attention to not

they did something bad but all the

there are people who are violating the

traffic laws then I go

driving brakes and put the beacon on

middle of the street I do not think that has

passed all not and one has to

dodge all this

it is justified and there are many

opportunities already seems the liveliness

criolla sa

if we get things by the

we are doing well

we take off and the rest instead of saying what

bad applauds is a live what I

passed reading a memory of 1777 is that

I saw it

it turns out that many years ago some

you will know there was a project for

end with the malones the time in the

war to the sun was avellaneda era

president avellaneda had a minister

of war that was called alcina and thus to

say and make a positive well go from

buenos aires a kind of pit

trench to see from Buenos Aires to

mendoza to avoid that if the

advanced aborigines when they came back with

the cattle with what they steal not

could happen we all know that that’s not

happened because he said he dies after rocks

in the desert campaign and what

solves in another way but the manager

to make that pit will be albert edenor

and order the other was an engineer

French that left those memories so

rich above us is what there is

us what he called the

Attention was that they celebrated doing

bad things

that is, it was contracted in each town to

who were going to make the pit hello the

ditch and they tried to rob the state or

heart of prices were these

things and the rest I celebrated it said

that they were alive and if they did not

were some sonos puts in his memory he

he says he translates it by telling the

French that means imbecile

You can not not think I understand not

I would have put something like that because he left

pretty bad about this country very very

sad and when we observe all this not

perfectly closes that the kingfisher

Iron is our main example

because the iron martyr was

thief was murderer was out of the

law did not want to work

borges what note says that if we

we would have taken the facundo instead

of al martín fierro as the example

perfect nationality

another would be our story

why because sarmiento gives it a name

to what we are for the first time through

of his phrases civilization and barbarism

the same branch was civilization and

barbarism and sought to change these

contradictions that we have through

The education

if he names this series of

values ​​and values that are opposed

all the time with us and not

they are only in our history or

in other attitudes are in our

language

we have phrases like I laugh

so as not to cry that they do not exist in another

part of the world

we started if we want to order something

positively we start with a no no

would have such a thing if we insult but of

affectionate way we use insults that are

loving sometimes they are not either

present in other towns

someone who is very good we tell him

it is a beast an animal if also

we are barbarians as something positive and the

word is totally negative and so

those contradictions are also seen in

what we expect

for example in education we

we expect a first class education but

when someone tells us that he is going to

study and that is dedicated to teaching

When I said that, I said that I wanted to be

teacher looked at me and told me

18 years but you give for more

I think that all those who have dedicated themselves to

teaching once they have told you or

we all have that with that idea that the

What he teaches is because he has no other

it does not give you anything else

while the teachers are the

next teachers but also

are the next doctors the

next engineers behind each

teacher to the future is the concept

that we have of education is

totally contradictory what

we look forward to education and although

we believe that we are god is true although

we have that idea that they are perfect g

for me it was breaking little by little

from and reflecting on this

we need for the time they tell us

if you are good

then the question that is asked

always to anyone who came to

Argentina is the faith that believes

argentina we hope you tell us what

good is fantastic Argentina or all

what can be or when something happens in

Argentina

we automatically search for the news

as reflected in the newspapers of

world

I do it I remember it’s closed decent

and Berga from Spain because they had a

great section for news

international because I was interested in seeing

what they said about Argentina not because I

interested in the world yes and so everyone does not know

can analyze more news and

we have how much space are you

dedicates nothing to the international

then ortega is also told that

we were a bit of a goal back we were

collective egotists yes and this either

is this new need that we

confirm that we are good and that

we wait all the time that’s not for

nothing new this appears as early as 1922 in the

argentina a very important dramatist

that was called bénavent is was

touring the different towns and cough

taking his work with lola membrives that

he was acting at that moment and then they arrive

to a town to rufino and picking up everything

what you want

the letters letters and the telegrams are

find out that it’s finally over

to be named the Nobel prize of

literature

then there was a huge stir

almost being fired because you all

they thought that he was finally going to come back

to Spain and finally decided to continue

for each town and keep his word

error because in every town that fell

as benavente is now such a man

important they asked him what he thought

about Argentina

the viewpoints did not respond

Joseph was repeated in each of the

pueblitos and it was already being done

on the ship to become Spain and a

despair so great they had

two for knowing what he thought about

we who navigators turned around

finally and told them if they want to know

what do I think about you weapons the only

possible word with the letters that

they make up the word Argentines

they all stood still they did not look and

they did not understand benavente got lost

between the boat crowd and went to

half an hour they realized that what

I got out of dealing with ignorant

I believe that they hope to have been very

negative with this talk

but what happened to me through me

charles see what are the errors that

I made a long time and not

that we are not so good let’s say and that

can change can be improved and I

it seems that to change one has to

have inspiration while having conscience

of all this sometimes when I put on

listen to my students sing the hymn

national

I have students who are children and

he heard singing with that force with that

love with that idea of ​​what it is that

is in the best country in the world and of

that everything is fine that everything will come out

all right

sometimes I started crying

listening to them because I do not want

leave them this I think that everyone can

change from its place what is wrong

if you first see it if you start taking

aware of that and behind that hymn

that hear those voices dating like

historian present to me a

bunch of men who did things

immense was this country men who

they left their lives men who worked

who fought that they did not dream of another

way if they did not stay with what

there was

I believe that as good in reality

us but to borges said in some

opportunity

every town has the gods that are

deser

it seems to me that we can deserve

another god we can work to change and

we can finally become that

promise that we have always been and is the

who warned us so many years ago

ortega does more

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *