Press "Enter" to skip to content

My Indianity : Confused Identity | Melizarani T Selva | TEDxGateway


[Music]

[Music] the Indian voice is a quiet one almost a

the Indian voice is a quiet one almost a

the Indian voice is a quiet one almost a whisper sometimes it even stutters as if

whisper sometimes it even stutters as if

whisper sometimes it even stutters as if it is unsure of its place in the world

it is unsure of its place in the world

it is unsure of its place in the world we are arguably the largest diaspora as

we are arguably the largest diaspora as

we are arguably the largest diaspora as our footprints are embedded in the soil

our footprints are embedded in the soil

our footprints are embedded in the soil of 206 nations across the planet and yet

of 206 nations across the planet and yet

of 206 nations across the planet and yet when it comes to speaking up our voice

when it comes to speaking up our voice

when it comes to speaking up our voice is hushed by migration and generation

is hushed by migration and generation

is hushed by migration and generation gaps we’ve moved so far away from the

gaps we’ve moved so far away from the

gaps we’ve moved so far away from the homeland in search of bigger houses and

homeland in search of bigger houses and

homeland in search of bigger houses and greener grass that we forgot what home

greener grass that we forgot what home

greener grass that we forgot what home actually feels like we built little

actually feels like we built little

actually feels like we built little India’s wherever we go and demand for

India’s wherever we go and demand for

India’s wherever we go and demand for more temples just to be in touch with

more temples just to be in touch with

more temples just to be in touch with our roots to give us a sense of being

our roots to give us a sense of being

our roots to give us a sense of being Indian in a place that is not India but

Indian in a place that is not India but

Indian in a place that is not India but the identity of the Indian person is a

the identity of the Indian person is a

the identity of the Indian person is a continuous tug-of-war between belonging

continuous tug-of-war between belonging

continuous tug-of-war between belonging to its own community and the world

to its own community and the world

to its own community and the world larger than itself I am a fourth

larger than itself I am a fourth

larger than itself I am a fourth generation Indian person born and raised

generation Indian person born and raised

generation Indian person born and raised in Malaysia which makes me a tiny dot in

in Malaysia which makes me a tiny dot in

in Malaysia which makes me a tiny dot in the 8.9% of my country’s total 27

the 8.9% of my country’s total 27

the 8.9% of my country’s total 27 million population my roots come from

million population my roots come from

million population my roots come from Bangalore on one side and Tamil Nadu on

Bangalore on one side and Tamil Nadu on

Bangalore on one side and Tamil Nadu on the other yet my feets are firmly

the other yet my feets are firmly

the other yet my feets are firmly planted in a place called Malaysia a

planted in a place called Malaysia a

planted in a place called Malaysia a land that I share with the Malay and

land that I share with the Malay and

land that I share with the Malay and Chinese communities that are constantly

Chinese communities that are constantly

Chinese communities that are constantly trying to decide if it wants to be a

trying to decide if it wants to be a

trying to decide if it wants to be a potpourri of cultures or a melting pot

potpourri of cultures or a melting pot

potpourri of cultures or a melting pot in fact there is a debate as to whether

in fact there is a debate as to whether

in fact there is a debate as to whether I am Malaysian Indian or Indian

I am Malaysian Indian or Indian

I am Malaysian Indian or Indian Malaysian meaning am i indian first or

Malaysian meaning am i indian first or

Malaysian meaning am i indian first or am i Indian at all and then there are

am i Indian at all and then there are

am i Indian at all and then there are other different constructs

other different constructs

other different constructs that for the deconstruct my identity

that for the deconstruct my identity

that for the deconstruct my identity like for instance at my Hindu or a my

like for instance at my Hindu or a my

like for instance at my Hindu or a my Tamil or a my South Indian this dilemma

Tamil or a my South Indian this dilemma

Tamil or a my South Indian this dilemma became the call of my master’s thesis

became the call of my master’s thesis

became the call of my master’s thesis instead of relying on handouts of who we

instead of relying on handouts of who we

instead of relying on handouts of who we are I wanted to know

are I wanted to know

are I wanted to know I studied the representation of the

I studied the representation of the

I studied the representation of the Malaysian Indian community in local

Malaysian Indian community in local

Malaysian Indian community in local television advertisements during

television advertisements during

television advertisements during Deepavali I wanted to know how do we

Deepavali I wanted to know how do we

Deepavali I wanted to know how do we define ourselves as India for decades we

define ourselves as India for decades we

define ourselves as India for decades we have been depicted on screen as

have been depicted on screen as

have been depicted on screen as melodramatic people we are either too

melodramatic people we are either too

melodramatic people we are either too loud too rough too pitiful or sometimes

loud too rough too pitiful or sometimes

loud too rough too pitiful or sometimes the reverse just plain comic relief’s

the reverse just plain comic relief’s

the reverse just plain comic relief’s this notion comes from the Indian

this notion comes from the Indian

this notion comes from the Indian immigrant impression that is embedded in

immigrant impression that is embedded in

immigrant impression that is embedded in Malaysian history needless to say it’s

Malaysian history needless to say it’s

Malaysian history needless to say it’s as though all the Indian minority

as though all the Indian minority

as though all the Indian minority communities are fresh off the boats such

communities are fresh off the boats such

communities are fresh off the boats such negative and outdated perceptions of the

negative and outdated perceptions of the

negative and outdated perceptions of the Indian community is the reason why

Indian community is the reason why

Indian community is the reason why stereotypes are built and brand our

stereotypes are built and brand our

stereotypes are built and brand our community and this as a result new

community and this as a result new

community and this as a result new generation of Indian people choose not

generation of Indian people choose not

generation of Indian people choose not to rejuvenate their identity instead

to rejuvenate their identity instead

to rejuvenate their identity instead they cast it aside or they cut corners

they cast it aside or they cut corners

they cast it aside or they cut corners to fit to belong because you see it’s

to fit to belong because you see it’s

to fit to belong because you see it’s not valuable to be Indian when you are a

not valuable to be Indian when you are a

not valuable to be Indian when you are a minority twenty-five years ago my Tamil

minority twenty-five years ago my Tamil

minority twenty-five years ago my Tamil tongued grandmother decided to learn

tongued grandmother decided to learn

tongued grandmother decided to learn English for the sake of her

English for the sake of her

English for the sake of her grandchildren she knew that the only way

grandchildren she knew that the only way

grandchildren she knew that the only way she could pass down her recipe for

she could pass down her recipe for

she could pass down her recipe for mutton curry and all that advice is by

mutton curry and all that advice is by

mutton curry and all that advice is by being able to talk to her grandchildren

being able to talk to her grandchildren

being able to talk to her grandchildren who are trying to become global citizens

who are trying to become global citizens

who are trying to become global citizens deep down I think my party knew that if

deep down I think my party knew that if

deep down I think my party knew that if she did not let go of her language she

she did not let go of her language she

she did not let go of her language she would lose her voice today I am a spoken

would lose her voice today I am a spoken

would lose her voice today I am a spoken word poet who believes in carrying her

word poet who believes in carrying her

word poet who believes in carrying her heritage on stage

heritage on stage

heritage on stage even if it sometimes comes with a little

even if it sometimes comes with a little

even if it sometimes comes with a little baggage but hey if you ain’t got baggage

baggage but hey if you ain’t got baggage

baggage but hey if you ain’t got baggage you ain’t got story I believe that we

you ain’t got story I believe that we

you ain’t got story I believe that we can carry our identity across border

can carry our identity across border

can carry our identity across border lines in to our bloodlines by educating

lines in to our bloodlines by educating

lines in to our bloodlines by educating our children with the tales of our times

our children with the tales of our times

our children with the tales of our times for me

for me

for me poetry is that instrument poetry is

poetry is that instrument poetry is

poetry is that instrument poetry is ageless timeless and it also saves time

ageless timeless and it also saves time

ageless timeless and it also saves time like right now right now I could show

like right now right now I could show

like right now right now I could show you pictorial slides of my research

you pictorial slides of my research

you pictorial slides of my research findings but instead I will leave you

findings but instead I will leave you

findings but instead I will leave you with a poem a poem about my Indiana tee

with a poem a poem about my Indiana tee

with a poem a poem about my Indiana tee I struggle with my identity or should I

I struggle with my identity or should I

I struggle with my identity or should I say my indian tea tea though I probably

say my indian tea tea though I probably

say my indian tea tea though I probably take Indian on tiny check boxes of

take Indian on tiny check boxes of

take Indian on tiny check boxes of forums trying to fit me into a category

forums trying to fit me into a category

forums trying to fit me into a category yet I am nothing but a statistic if the

yet I am nothing but a statistic if the

yet I am nothing but a statistic if the category denies me denying my stubborn

category denies me denying my stubborn

category denies me denying my stubborn Tom taking after the tyrants to colonize

Tom taking after the tyrants to colonize

Tom taking after the tyrants to colonize my ancestors instead of my mother’s own

my ancestors instead of my mother’s own

my ancestors instead of my mother’s own tongue it’s not my fault that you’re

tongue it’s not my fault that you’re

tongue it’s not my fault that you’re sensitive and highly strung

sensitive and highly strung

sensitive and highly strung because I call my upper daddy because

because I call my upper daddy because

because I call my upper daddy because Melissa sounds so English before it ends

Melissa sounds so English before it ends

Melissa sounds so English before it ends with Ronnie do I need to eat on banana

with Ronnie do I need to eat on banana

with Ronnie do I need to eat on banana leaves with my hands to pledge

leaves with my hands to pledge

leaves with my hands to pledge allegiance to the UH next to me our life

allegiance to the UH next to me our life

allegiance to the UH next to me our life forever be condemned to be a minority of

forever be condemned to be a minority of

forever be condemned to be a minority of the minority who would rather order

the minority who would rather order

the minority who would rather order passe in Malay because she can barely

passe in Malay because she can barely

passe in Malay because she can barely count to three without getting cringes

count to three without getting cringes

count to three without getting cringes flinches and stairs wooden Linda and you

flinches and stairs wooden Linda and you

flinches and stairs wooden Linda and you laugh at me tease me to my face and

laugh at me tease me to my face and

laugh at me tease me to my face and curse my family who raised a girl who

curse my family who raised a girl who

curse my family who raised a girl who are dresses

are dresses

are dresses instead of saris at weddings where I

instead of saris at weddings where I

instead of saris at weddings where I should be paired to my husband-to-be

should be paired to my husband-to-be

should be paired to my husband-to-be alas it is my chastity that you question

alas it is my chastity that you question

alas it is my chastity that you question because no black for two decorates this

because no black for two decorates this

because no black for two decorates this forehead of ambition get straight A’s

forehead of ambition get straight A’s

forehead of ambition get straight A’s for the final exams for the community

for the final exams for the community

for the final exams for the community and the coda go to university be a

and the coda go to university be a

and the coda go to university be a doctor and make us proud karna we

doctor and make us proud karna we

doctor and make us proud karna we Indians must stick together and be there

Indians must stick together and be there

Indians must stick together and be there for each other but on my graduation day

for each other but on my graduation day

for each other but on my graduation day you tell me mass comm is not in favor

you tell me mass comm is not in favor

you tell me mass comm is not in favor my degree can’t make me an engineer but

my degree can’t make me an engineer but

my degree can’t make me an engineer but I can read your news Vanakkam say

I can read your news Vanakkam say

I can read your news Vanakkam say Vaseline on that so teach me so teach me

Vaseline on that so teach me so teach me

Vaseline on that so teach me so teach me and I will say more than the

and I will say more than the

and I will say more than the introduction give me a chance to make up

introduction give me a chance to make up

introduction give me a chance to make up for my a plus English tuition despising

for my a plus English tuition despising

for my a plus English tuition despising the language you so crudely mentioned

the language you so crudely mentioned

the language you so crudely mentioned the lack of my ability and questions my

the lack of my ability and questions my

the lack of my ability and questions my spirituality when you’re the one who

spirituality when you’re the one who

spirituality when you’re the one who taught the people a string of our native

taught the people a string of our native

taught the people a string of our native obscenities my bloodlines run deep along

obscenities my bloodlines run deep along

obscenities my bloodlines run deep along the rivers of the holy Ganga to Tamil

the rivers of the holy Ganga to Tamil

the rivers of the holy Ganga to Tamil Nadu Bangalore and Karnataka I may not

Nadu Bangalore and Karnataka I may not

Nadu Bangalore and Karnataka I may not kneel and pray like you but I believe in

kneel and pray like you but I believe in

kneel and pray like you but I believe in karma which I thought you did but you

karma which I thought you did but you

karma which I thought you did but you stuck to bar brawls and self-righteous

stuck to bar brawls and self-righteous

stuck to bar brawls and self-righteous gangsters yes I know you didn’t do it

gangsters yes I know you didn’t do it

gangsters yes I know you didn’t do it must you take to the streets to prove

must you take to the streets to prove

must you take to the streets to prove your innocence wave your picket slides

your innocence wave your picket slides

your innocence wave your picket slides and throw stones at the government

and throw stones at the government

and throw stones at the government representatives who you claimed know

representatives who you claimed know

representatives who you claimed know nothing of your plight and whoa because

nothing of your plight and whoa because

nothing of your plight and whoa because they build the tamil schools you refused

they build the tamil schools you refused

they build the tamil schools you refused to go sponsor your babies and businesses

to go sponsor your babies and businesses

to go sponsor your babies and businesses and for corrupt need to make a stand

and for corrupt need to make a stand

and for corrupt need to make a stand that we are significant as an 8% and

that we are significant as an 8% and

that we are significant as an 8% and they said and they said and they said

they said and they said and they said

they said and they said and they said numba gain trust that tomorrow will be a

numba gain trust that tomorrow will be a

numba gain trust that tomorrow will be a better day

better day

better day but Trust is blind when that is the only

but Trust is blind when that is the only

but Trust is blind when that is the only tamil word they can say to cover empty

tamil word they can say to cover empty

tamil word they can say to cover empty promises and get your board with free

promises and get your board with free

promises and get your board with free Brioni dinners there are no Saints

Brioni dinners there are no Saints

Brioni dinners there are no Saints because we’re all sinners while they’re

because we’re all sinners while they’re

because we’re all sinners while they’re greedy for power only greedier not

greedy for power only greedier not

greedy for power only greedier not enough Mahalo for more temples and

enough Mahalo for more temples and

enough Mahalo for more temples and festival holidays and discounts for my

festival holidays and discounts for my

festival holidays and discounts for my brother who chose the param 2 here

brother who chose the param 2 here

brother who chose the param 2 here drogyny and easy money because it paid

drogyny and easy money because it paid

drogyny and easy money because it paid the bills and he could have sit through

the bills and he could have sit through

the bills and he could have sit through a law degree forgive me but hell hath no

a law degree forgive me but hell hath no

a law degree forgive me but hell hath no fury like a woman scorned because she

fury like a woman scorned because she

fury like a woman scorned because she chose friends lighter than her shade of

chose friends lighter than her shade of

chose friends lighter than her shade of brown or darker on the color palette

brown or darker on the color palette

brown or darker on the color palette from white to black and you frown at me

from white to black and you frown at me

from white to black and you frown at me wondering why I didn’t stick to the clan

wondering why I didn’t stick to the clan

wondering why I didn’t stick to the clan the Indian boy was good enough but I

the Indian boy was good enough but I

the Indian boy was good enough but I wanted a man

and I watched you grinding your teeth

and I watched you grinding your teeth chewing at what is hard to swallow at

chewing at what is hard to swallow at

chewing at what is hard to swallow at principals and traditions you don’t

principals and traditions you don’t

principals and traditions you don’t understand but follow knowing that

understand but follow knowing that

understand but follow knowing that you’ll be frowned upon if you told me to

you’ll be frowned upon if you told me to

you’ll be frowned upon if you told me to stick to my own kind but you already are

stick to my own kind but you already are

stick to my own kind but you already are cuz when you’re my daddy daughter comes

cuz when you’re my daddy daughter comes

cuz when you’re my daddy daughter comes home with a punjabi it’s not fine but I

home with a punjabi it’s not fine but I

home with a punjabi it’s not fine but I hold out my hand with you seeking your

hold out my hand with you seeking your

hold out my hand with you seeking your acceptance beneath my frustration and

acceptance beneath my frustration and

acceptance beneath my frustration and expensive education to read our history

expensive education to read our history

expensive education to read our history locate our past and affirm the present

locate our past and affirm the present

locate our past and affirm the present shine the dim future and light the

shine the dim future and light the

shine the dim future and light the pathway for our descendants so look and

pathway for our descendants so look and

pathway for our descendants so look and what you have in the palm of your hands

what you have in the palm of your hands

what you have in the palm of your hands and look no further we’ve sat down too

and look no further we’ve sat down too

and look no further we’ve sat down too long at the buzz of earnest cafes

long at the buzz of earnest cafes

long at the buzz of earnest cafes blaming each other for what we can’t

blaming each other for what we can’t

blaming each other for what we can’t have don’t have should have when we

have don’t have should have when we

have don’t have should have when we already have the human ability to

already have the human ability to

already have the human ability to succeed in all that we choose to be

succeed in all that we choose to be

succeed in all that we choose to be remember that a community with problems

remember that a community with problems

remember that a community with problems is different from a problem community

[Applause]

[Applause] between Barton Adam spins and tabla

between Barton Adam spins and tabla

between Barton Adam spins and tabla beats you and I are no different so

beats you and I are no different so

beats you and I are no different so polish your culture armor and let all

polish your culture armor and let all

polish your culture armor and let all grudges go life may be rough but it need

grudges go life may be rough but it need

grudges go life may be rough but it need not be another Vijay TV episode though I

not be another Vijay TV episode though I

not be another Vijay TV episode though I didn’t climb Everest or started a line I

didn’t climb Everest or started a line I

didn’t climb Everest or started a line I can’t make that curry to save my life

can’t make that curry to save my life

can’t make that curry to save my life and I’m not defined but accept me as I

and I’m not defined but accept me as I

and I’m not defined but accept me as I accept you with arms open wide because I

accept you with arms open wide because I

accept you with arms open wide because I choose to take India as I am on the

choose to take India as I am on the

choose to take India as I am on the inside

inside

inside [Applause]

you

you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *