Press "Enter" to skip to content

Some Truths About Honesty | Alexander Wagner | TEDxZurich


how many companies have you interacted

how many companies have you interacted with today well you’ve got up in the

with today well you’ve got up in the

with today well you’ve got up in the morning took a shower or stir hair just

morning took a shower or stir hair just

morning took a shower or stir hair just a hair dryer net breakfast eight cereals

a hair dryer net breakfast eight cereals

a hair dryer net breakfast eight cereals fruit yogurt whatever had coffee tea you

fruit yogurt whatever had coffee tea you

fruit yogurt whatever had coffee tea you took public transfer to come here or

took public transfer to come here or

took public transfer to come here or maybe used to your private car you

maybe used to your private car you

maybe used to your private car you interacted with the company that you

interacted with the company that you

interacted with the company that you work for or that you own you interacted

work for or that you own you interacted

work for or that you own you interacted with your clients your customers and so

with your clients your customers and so

with your clients your customers and so on and so forth I’m pretty sure there

on and so forth I’m pretty sure there

on and so forth I’m pretty sure there are at least seven companies you’ve

are at least seven companies you’ve

are at least seven companies you’ve interacted with today let me tell you a

interacted with today let me tell you a

interacted with today let me tell you a stunning statistic one out of seven

stunning statistic one out of seven

stunning statistic one out of seven large public corporations commit fraud

large public corporations commit fraud

large public corporations commit fraud every year this is a u.s. academic study

every year this is a u.s. academic study

every year this is a u.s. academic study that looks at US companies I have no

that looks at US companies I have no

that looks at US companies I have no reason to believe that’s different in

reason to believe that’s different in

reason to believe that’s different in Europe this is a study that looks at

Europe this is a study that looks at

Europe this is a study that looks at both detected and undetected fraud using

both detected and undetected fraud using

both detected and undetected fraud using statistical methods this is not petty

statistical methods this is not petty

statistical methods this is not petty fraud these frauds cost the shareholders

fraud these frauds cost the shareholders

fraud these frauds cost the shareholders of these companies and therefore society

of these companies and therefore society

of these companies and therefore society on the order of three hundred and eighty

on the order of three hundred and eighty

on the order of three hundred and eighty billion dollars per year we can all

billion dollars per year we can all

billion dollars per year we can all think of some examples right the car

think of some examples right the car

think of some examples right the car industry’s secrets aren’t quite so

industry’s secrets aren’t quite so

industry’s secrets aren’t quite so secret anymore fraud has become a

secret anymore fraud has become a

secret anymore fraud has become a feature not a bug of the financial

feature not a bug of the financial

feature not a bug of the financial services industry That’s not me who’s

services industry That’s not me who’s

services industry That’s not me who’s claiming that that’s the president of

claiming that that’s the president of

claiming that that’s the president of the American Finance Association who

the American Finance Association who

the American Finance Association who stated that in his presidential address

stated that in his presidential address

stated that in his presidential address that’s a huge problem if you think about

that’s a huge problem if you think about

that’s a huge problem if you think about especially an economy like Switzerland

especially an economy like Switzerland

especially an economy like Switzerland which relies so much on the trust put

which relies so much on the trust put

which relies so much on the trust put into its financial industry on the other

into its financial industry on the other

into its financial industry on the other hand there are six out of seven

hand there are six out of seven

hand there are six out of seven companies who actually remain honest

companies who actually remain honest

companies who actually remain honest despite all temptations to start

despite all temptations to start

despite all temptations to start engaging in fraud there are

engaging in fraud there are

engaging in fraud there are whistleblowers like Michael Woodford who

whistleblowers like Michael Woodford who

whistleblowers like Michael Woodford who blew the whistle on Olympus these

blew the whistle on Olympus these

blew the whistle on Olympus these whistleblowers risk their careers their

whistleblowers risk their careers their

whistleblowers risk their careers their friendships to bring out the truth about

friendships to bring out the truth about

friendships to bring out the truth about their companies there are journalists

their companies there are journalists

their companies there are journalists like Anna Politkovskaya who risk even

like Anna Politkovskaya who risk even

like Anna Politkovskaya who risk even their lives to report human rights

their lives to report human rights

their lives to report human rights violations she got killed every year

violations she got killed every year

violations she got killed every year around 100 journalists get killed

around 100 journalists get killed

around 100 journalists get killed because of their conviction to bring out

because of their conviction to bring out

because of their conviction to bring out the truth so in my talk today I want to

the truth so in my talk today I want to

the truth so in my talk today I want to share with you some insights I’ve

share with you some insights I’ve

share with you some insights I’ve obtained and learned in the last 10

obtained and learned in the last 10

obtained and learned in the last 10 years of conducting research on this I’m

years of conducting research on this I’m

years of conducting research on this I’m a researcher scientist working with

a researcher scientist working with

a researcher scientist working with economists financial economists

economists financial economists

economists financial economists ethicists neuroscientists lawyers and

ethicists neuroscientists lawyers and

ethicists neuroscientists lawyers and others trying to understand what makes

others trying to understand what makes

others trying to understand what makes humans tick and how can we address this

humans tick and how can we address this

humans tick and how can we address this issue of fraud in corporations and

issue of fraud in corporations and

issue of fraud in corporations and therefore contribute to the improvement

therefore contribute to the improvement

therefore contribute to the improvement of the world I want to start by sharing

of the world I want to start by sharing

of the world I want to start by sharing with you two very distinct visions of

with you two very distinct visions of

with you two very distinct visions of how people behave first meet Adam Smith

how people behave first meet Adam Smith

how people behave first meet Adam Smith founding father of modern economics his

founding father of modern economics his

founding father of modern economics his basic idea was that if everybody behaves

basic idea was that if everybody behaves

basic idea was that if everybody behaves in their own self-interest that’s good

in their own self-interest that’s good

in their own self-interest that’s good for everybody in the end self-interest

for everybody in the end self-interest

for everybody in the end self-interest isn’t a merrily defined concept just for

isn’t a merrily defined concept just for

isn’t a merrily defined concept just for your immediate utility it has a long

your immediate utility it has a long

your immediate utility it has a long around implication let’s think about

around implication let’s think about

around implication let’s think about that think about this dog here that

that think about this dog here that

that think about this dog here that might be us all right there’s this

might be us all right there’s this

might be us all right there’s this temptation I apologize to all

temptation I apologize to all

temptation I apologize to all vegetarians but you know dogs do like

vegetarians but you know dogs do like

vegetarians but you know dogs do like the bratwurst

the bratwurst

the bratwurst now the straight-up self-interested move

now the straight-up self-interested move

now the straight-up self-interested move here is to go for that so my friend Adam

here is to go for that so my friend Adam

here is to go for that so my friend Adam here might jump up get the sausage and

here might jump up get the sausage and

here might jump up get the sausage and thereby ruining all this beautiful

thereby ruining all this beautiful

thereby ruining all this beautiful tableware

tableware

tableware but that’s not what Adam Smith meant he

but that’s not what Adam Smith meant he

but that’s not what Adam Smith meant he didn’t mean disregard all consequences

didn’t mean disregard all consequences

didn’t mean disregard all consequences to the contrary he would have thought

to the contrary he would have thought

to the contrary he would have thought well there may be negative consequences

well there may be negative consequences

well there may be negative consequences for example the owner might be angry

for example the owner might be angry

for example the owner might be angry with the dog and the dog anticipating

with the dog and the dog anticipating

with the dog and the dog anticipating that might not behave in this way

that might not behave in this way

that might not behave in this way right that might be us weighing the

right that might be us weighing the

right that might be us weighing the benefits and costs of our actions how

benefits and costs of our actions how

benefits and costs of our actions how does that play out well many of you I’m

does that play out well many of you I’m

does that play out well many of you I’m sure have in your companies especially

sure have in your companies especially

sure have in your companies especially if it’s a large company a cow

if it’s a large company a cow

if it’s a large company a cow of conduct and then if you behave

of conduct and then if you behave

of conduct and then if you behave according to that code of conduct that

according to that code of conduct that

according to that code of conduct that improves your chances of getting a bonus

improves your chances of getting a bonus

improves your chances of getting a bonus payment and on the other hand if you

payment and on the other hand if you

payment and on the other hand if you disregard it

disregard it

disregard it then there are higher chances of not

then there are higher chances of not

then there are higher chances of not getting your bonus or it’s being

getting your bonus or it’s being

getting your bonus or it’s being diminished in other words this is a very

diminished in other words this is a very

diminished in other words this is a very economic motivation of trying to get

economic motivation of trying to get

economic motivation of trying to get people to be more honest or more aligned

people to be more honest or more aligned

people to be more honest or more aligned with the corporation’s principles

with the corporation’s principles

with the corporation’s principles similarly reputation is a very powerful

similarly reputation is a very powerful

similarly reputation is a very powerful economic force right we try to build a

economic force right we try to build a

economic force right we try to build a reputation maybe for being honest

reputation maybe for being honest

reputation maybe for being honest because then people trust us more in the

because then people trust us more in the

because then people trust us more in the future right Adam Smith talked about the

future right Adam Smith talked about the

future right Adam Smith talked about the Baker who is not producing good bread

Baker who is not producing good bread

Baker who is not producing good bread out of his benevolence for those people

out of his benevolence for those people

out of his benevolence for those people who consume the bread but because he

who consume the bread but because he

who consume the bread but because he wants to sell more future bread in my

wants to sell more future bread in my

wants to sell more future bread in my research we find for example at the

research we find for example at the

research we find for example at the University of Zurich that Swiss banks

University of Zurich that Swiss banks

University of Zurich that Swiss banks who get caught up in media and in the

who get caught up in media and in the

who get caught up in media and in the context for example of tax evasion of

context for example of tax evasion of

context for example of tax evasion of tax fraud have bad media coverage they

tax fraud have bad media coverage they

tax fraud have bad media coverage they lose net new money in the future and

lose net new money in the future and

lose net new money in the future and therefore make lower profits that’s a

therefore make lower profits that’s a

therefore make lower profits that’s a very powerful reputational force

very powerful reputational force

very powerful reputational force benefits and costs here’s another

benefits and costs here’s another

benefits and costs here’s another viewpoint of the world meet Immanuel

viewpoint of the world meet Immanuel

viewpoint of the world meet Immanuel Kant 18th century German philosopher

Kant 18th century German philosopher

Kant 18th century German philosopher superstar he developed this notion that

superstar he developed this notion that

superstar he developed this notion that independent of the consequences some

independent of the consequences some

independent of the consequences some actions are just right and some are just

actions are just right and some are just

actions are just right and some are just wrong it’s just wrong to lie for example

wrong it’s just wrong to lie for example

wrong it’s just wrong to lie for example so meet my friend Emmanuel here he knows

so meet my friend Emmanuel here he knows

so meet my friend Emmanuel here he knows he had a sausage is very tasty but he’s

he had a sausage is very tasty but he’s

he had a sausage is very tasty but he’s gonna turn away because he’s a good dog

gonna turn away because he’s a good dog

gonna turn away because he’s a good dog he knows it’s wrong to jump up and risk

he knows it’s wrong to jump up and risk

he knows it’s wrong to jump up and risk ruining all this beautiful tableware if

ruining all this beautiful tableware if

ruining all this beautiful tableware if you believe that people are motivated

you believe that people are motivated

you believe that people are motivated like that then all this stuff about

like that then all this stuff about

like that then all this stuff about incentives all this stuff about code of

incentives all this stuff about code of

incentives all this stuff about code of conduct and bonus systems and so on

conduct and bonus systems and so on

conduct and bonus systems and so on doesn’t make a whole lot of sense that

doesn’t make a whole lot of sense that

doesn’t make a whole lot of sense that people are motivated by different values

people are motivated by different values

people are motivated by different values perhaps so what are people actually

perhaps so what are people actually

perhaps so what are people actually motivated

motivated

motivated or goodbye right these two gentlemen

or goodbye right these two gentlemen

or goodbye right these two gentlemen here have perfect hairdo but they give

here have perfect hairdo but they give

here have perfect hairdo but they give us very different views of the world

us very different views of the world

us very different views of the world what do we do with this well I’m an

what do we do with this well I’m an

what do we do with this well I’m an economist and we conduct so-called

economist and we conduct so-called

economist and we conduct so-called experiments to address this issue we

experiments to address this issue we

experiments to address this issue we strip away facts which are confusing in

strip away facts which are confusing in

strip away facts which are confusing in reality reality is so rich there’s so

reality reality is so rich there’s so

reality reality is so rich there’s so much going on it’s almost impossible to

much going on it’s almost impossible to

much going on it’s almost impossible to know what drives people’s behavior

know what drives people’s behavior

know what drives people’s behavior really so let’s do a little experiment

really so let’s do a little experiment

really so let’s do a little experiment together imagine the following situation

together imagine the following situation

together imagine the following situation you’re in a room alone not like here

you’re in a room alone not like here

you’re in a room alone not like here there’s a five franc coin like the one

there’s a five franc coin like the one

there’s a five franc coin like the one I’m holding up right now in front of you

I’m holding up right now in front of you

I’m holding up right now in front of you here are your instructions toss the coin

here are your instructions toss the coin

here are your instructions toss the coin four times and then on a computer

four times and then on a computer

four times and then on a computer terminal in front of you enter the

terminal in front of you enter the

terminal in front of you enter the number of times

number of times

number of times tails came up this is the situation

tails came up this is the situation

tails came up this is the situation here’s the rub for every time you

here’s the rub for every time you

here’s the rub for every time you announce that you had a tails throw you

announce that you had a tails throw you

announce that you had a tails throw you get paid five francs so if you say I had

get paid five francs so if you say I had

get paid five francs so if you say I had two tails throws you get paid ten francs

two tails throws you get paid ten francs

two tails throws you get paid ten francs if you say you have zero you get paid

if you say you have zero you get paid

if you say you have zero you get paid zero friends if you say I had four tails

zero friends if you say I had four tails

zero friends if you say I had four tails throws then you get paid 20 francs it’s

throws then you get paid 20 francs it’s

throws then you get paid 20 francs it’s anonymous nobody’s watching what you’re

anonymous nobody’s watching what you’re

anonymous nobody’s watching what you’re doing and you get paid that money

doing and you get paid that money

doing and you get paid that money anonymously I got two questions for you

you know what’s coming on right first

you know what’s coming on right first how would you behave in that situation

how would you behave in that situation

how would you behave in that situation the second look to your left and look to

the second look to your left and look to

the second look to your left and look to your right and think about how the

your right and think about how the

your right and think about how the person sitting next to you might behave

person sitting next to you might behave

person sitting next to you might behave in that situation we did this experiment

in that situation we did this experiment

in that situation we did this experiment for real we did it at the Manifesta art

for real we did it at the Manifesta art

for real we did it at the Manifesta art exhibition that took place here in

exhibition that took place here in

exhibition that took place here in Zurich recently not with students in the

Zurich recently not with students in the

Zurich recently not with students in the lab at the university but with the real

lab at the university but with the real

lab at the university but with the real population like you guys first a quick

population like you guys first a quick

population like you guys first a quick reminder of stats if I throw the coin

reminder of stats if I throw the coin

reminder of stats if I throw the coin four times and it’s a fair coin then the

four times and it’s a fair coin then the

four times and it’s a fair coin then the probability that it comes up four times

probability that it comes up four times

probability that it comes up four times tails is six point twenty five percent

tails is six point twenty five percent

tails is six point twenty five percent and I hope you can intuitively see that

and I hope you can intuitively see that

and I hope you can intuitively see that the probability that all four of them

the probability that all four of them

the probability that all four of them are tails is much lower than two of them

are tails is much lower than two of them

are tails is much lower than two of them are tails right here’s what happened

are tails right here’s what happened

are tails right here’s what happened people did this experiment for real

people did this experiment for real

people did this experiment for real around thirty five to thirty to thirty

around thirty five to thirty to thirty

around thirty five to thirty to thirty five percent of people said well I had

five percent of people said well I had

five percent of people said well I had four tails throws that’s extremely

four tails throws that’s extremely

four tails throws that’s extremely unlikely but the really amazing thing

unlikely but the really amazing thing

unlikely but the really amazing thing here perhaps to an economist is there

here perhaps to an economist is there

here perhaps to an economist is there are around 65 percent of people who did

are around 65 percent of people who did

are around 65 percent of people who did not say I had four tails throws even

not say I had four tails throws even

not say I had four tails throws even though in that situation nobody is

though in that situation nobody is

though in that situation nobody is watching you the only consequence that’s

watching you the only consequence that’s

watching you the only consequence that’s in place is you get more money if you

in place is you get more money if you

in place is you get more money if you say four then less you leave twenty

say four then less you leave twenty

say four then less you leave twenty francs on the table by announcing maybe

francs on the table by announcing maybe

francs on the table by announcing maybe zero I don’t know whether the people the

zero I don’t know whether the people the

zero I don’t know whether the people the other people over honest or whether they

other people over honest or whether they

other people over honest or whether they also said a little bit higher or lower

also said a little bit higher or lower

also said a little bit higher or lower than what they did because it’s

than what they did because it’s

than what they did because it’s anonymous we only observe the

anonymous we only observe the

anonymous we only observe the distribution but what I can tell you and

distribution but what I can tell you and

distribution but what I can tell you and here’s another coin toss there you go

here’s another coin toss there you go

here’s another coin toss there you go it’s tails all right

it’s tails all right

it’s tails all right but don’t don’t check okay but I can

but don’t don’t check okay but I can

but don’t don’t check okay but I can tell you is that not everybody behaved

tell you is that not everybody behaved

tell you is that not everybody behaved like Adam Smith would have predicted

like Adam Smith would have predicted

like Adam Smith would have predicted that so what does that leave us with

that so what does that leave us with

that so what does that leave us with well it seems people are motivated by

well it seems people are motivated by

well it seems people are motivated by certain intrinsic values and in our

certain intrinsic values and in our

certain intrinsic values and in our research we look at this we look at the

research we look at this we look at the

research we look at this we look at the idea that people have so-called

idea that people have so-called

idea that people have so-called protected values a protected value isn’t

protected values a protected value isn’t

protected values a protected value isn’t just any value and protected value is a

just any value and protected value is a

just any value and protected value is a value where you’re willing to pay a

value where you’re willing to pay a

value where you’re willing to pay a price to uphold that value you are

price to uphold that value you are

price to uphold that value you are willing to pay a price to withstand the

willing to pay a price to withstand the

willing to pay a price to withstand the temptation to give in and the

temptation to give in and the

temptation to give in and the consequence is you feel better if you

consequence is you feel better if you

consequence is you feel better if you earn money in a way that’s consistent

earn money in a way that’s consistent

earn money in a way that’s consistent with your values let me show you this

with your values let me show you this

with your values let me show you this again in the metaphor of our beloved dog

again in the metaphor of our beloved dog

again in the metaphor of our beloved dog here if we succeed in getting the

here if we succeed in getting the

here if we succeed in getting the sausage without violating our values

sausage without violating our values

sausage without violating our values then the sausage tastes better that’s

then the sausage tastes better that’s

then the sausage tastes better that’s what our research shows if on the other

what our research shows if on the other

what our research shows if on the other hand we do so if we get the sausage and

hand we do so if we get the sausage and

hand we do so if we get the sausage and in doing so we actually violate values

in doing so we actually violate values

in doing so we actually violate values the value the sausage less

the value the sausage less

the value the sausage less quantitatively that’s quite powerful we

quantitatively that’s quite powerful we

quantitatively that’s quite powerful we can measure these protected values for

can measure these protected values for

can measure these protected values for example by a survey measure simple 9

example by a survey measure simple 9

example by a survey measure simple 9 item survey that’s quite predictive in

item survey that’s quite predictive in

item survey that’s quite predictive in these experiments if you think about the

these experiments if you think about the

these experiments if you think about the average of the population and then

average of the population and then

average of the population and then there’s a distribution around that

there’s a distribution around that

there’s a distribution around that people are different we all are

people are different we all are

people are different we all are different people who have a set of

different people who have a set of

different people who have a set of protected values that’s one standard

protected values that’s one standard

protected values that’s one standard deviation above the average they

deviation above the average they

deviation above the average they discount money they receive by lying by

discount money they receive by lying by

discount money they receive by lying by about 25 percent that means a dollar

about 25 percent that means a dollar

about 25 percent that means a dollar received when lying is worth to them

received when lying is worth to them

received when lying is worth to them only 75 cents without any incentives you

only 75 cents without any incentives you

only 75 cents without any incentives you put in place for them to behave honestly

put in place for them to behave honestly

put in place for them to behave honestly it’s their intrinsic motivation by the

it’s their intrinsic motivation by the

it’s their intrinsic motivation by the way I’m not a moral authority I’m not

way I’m not a moral authority I’m not

way I’m not a moral authority I’m not saying I have all these beautiful values

saying I have all these beautiful values

saying I have all these beautiful values right but I’m interested in how people

right but I’m interested in how people

right but I’m interested in how people behave in how we can leverage that

behave in how we can leverage that

behave in how we can leverage that richness in human nature to actually

richness in human nature to actually

richness in human nature to actually improve the workings of our

improve the workings of our

improve the workings of our organizations

organizations

organizations so there are two very very different

so there are two very very different

so there are two very very different visions here on the one hand you can

visions here on the one hand you can

visions here on the one hand you can appeal to benefits and costs and try to

appeal to benefits and costs and try to

appeal to benefits and costs and try to get people to behave according to them

get people to behave according to them

get people to behave according to them on the other hand you can select people

on the other hand you can select people

on the other hand you can select people who have the values and the desirable

who have the values and the desirable

who have the values and the desirable characteristics of course competencies

characteristics of course competencies

characteristics of course competencies that go in line with your organization I

that go in line with your organization I

that go in line with your organization I do not yet know where these protected

do not yet know where these protected

do not yet know where these protected values really come from is it nurture or

values really come from is it nurture or

values really come from is it nurture or is it nature what I can tell you is that

is it nature what I can tell you is that

is it nature what I can tell you is that the distribution looks pretty similar

the distribution looks pretty similar

the distribution looks pretty similar for men and women it looks pretty

for men and women it looks pretty

for men and women it looks pretty similar for those who had studied

similar for those who had studied

similar for those who had studied economics or those who had studied

economics or those who had studied

economics or those who had studied psychology it looks even principled

psychology it looks even principled

psychology it looks even principled around different age categories among

around different age categories among

around different age categories among adults but I don’t know yet how this

adults but I don’t know yet how this

adults but I don’t know yet how this develops over a lifetime that will be

develops over a lifetime that will be

develops over a lifetime that will be the subject of future research the idea

the subject of future research the idea

the subject of future research the idea I want to leave you with is it’s alright

I want to leave you with is it’s alright

I want to leave you with is it’s alright to appeal to incentives I’m an economist

to appeal to incentives I’m an economist

to appeal to incentives I’m an economist I certainly believe in the fact that

I certainly believe in the fact that

I certainly believe in the fact that incentives work but do you think about

incentives work but do you think about

incentives work but do you think about selecting the right people rather than

selecting the right people rather than

selecting the right people rather than having people and then putting

having people and then putting

having people and then putting incentives in place

incentives in place

incentives in place selecting the right people with the

selecting the right people with the

selecting the right people with the right values may go a long way to saving

right values may go a long way to saving

right values may go a long way to saving a lot of trouble and a lot of money in

a lot of trouble and a lot of money in

a lot of trouble and a lot of money in your organizations in other words it

your organizations in other words it

your organizations in other words it will pay off to put people first thank

will pay off to put people first thank

will pay off to put people first thank you

you

you [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] you

you

you [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *